Background and why this matters

A tax audit is an examination by the IRS (or a state tax agency) to verify that the income, deductions and credits on a return are correct. Most taxpayers are never audited, but certain patterns increase the chance that your return will be selected for review. The IRS uses computerized systems, third‑party information (W‑2s, 1099s), and targeted enforcement programs to find returns that deviate from normal peer behavior or contain inconsistencies (IRS Data Book; IRS Audit Selection). Accurate reporting and clear documentation are your best defenses.

How the IRS selects returns (plain language)

  • Automated screening and filters: The IRS compares returns to statistical models and prior returns. Returns that look unusual for a taxpayer’s filing group can get flagged. The IRS also uses a discriminant function system (DIF) and other score‑based tools to identify returns with higher risk of error or fraud (IRS guidance).
  • Third‑party matches: W‑2s, 1099s and bank reports are matched to what you report. Mismatches—like unreported 1099‑NEC income—are common audit triggers because the IRS receives the same data from payers.
  • Information referrals and whistleblowers: Tips from third parties or referrals from other agencies can prompt audits.
  • Random and targeted programs: Some audits are part of broader compliance campaigns (e.g., passthrough entity enforcement, virtual currency reporting).

Common triggers and concrete examples

Below are the patterns most likely to attract IRS attention, with short examples you can relate to.

  • Large deductions compared with income: If your deductions are unusually large for your income or for others in your occupation (for example, sizable Schedule C losses year after year on a modest‑income business), the return may be flagged. In practice I’ve seen small business owners repeatedly claim large travel, meals, or home‑office deductions without matching documentation and trigger correspondence audits.

  • Income mismatches (underreported 1099s/W‑2s): The IRS cross‑checks employer and payer reports. Missing or understated 1099‑NEC or Form 1099‑K income often causes notices and audits. Always reconcile your records with the 1099s you receive.

  • Excessive charitable deductions: Claims of large charitable donations without proper receipts or acknowledgement forms (needed for gifts of $250 or more) invite scrutiny. Keep contemporaneous receipts and donor acknowledgements (IRS Publication 526).

  • Unusual business deductions and Schedule C issues: Personal expenses claimed as business expenses, disproportionately large meals & entertainment, or a home office deduction that doesn’t meet the rules can all lead to further review. Publication 587 explains home‑office rules and the documentation required.

  • High income and complex returns: Higher‑income taxpayers and those with complex investments, multiple entities, or significant foreign activity see higher selection rates.

  • Frequent amended returns or repeated errors: Repeated corrections can cause the IRS to examine prior years more closely.

  • Large cash transactions or suspicious activity reports: Large cash deposits, third‑party settlements, or Form 1099‑C/1099‑A events that don’t align with reported income can raise flags.

How serious are audits? (a realistic view)

Most audits are limited and can be resolved by providing documentation. The IRS conducts correspondence audits by mail, office audits where you meet an examiner, and field audits at your home or business for deeper reviews. If adjustments are proposed, you can agree, negotiate, or appeal. In my practice, timely, organized documentation often ends an audit quickly; lack of records is the most common cause of unfavorable outcomes.

Practical steps to reduce audit risk (actionable checklist)

  1. Reconcile third‑party forms before filing
  • Match your W‑2s, 1099‑NEC/1099‑K, and brokerage statements to your prepared return. If forms are missing or incorrect, contact the payer immediately and keep written records of your outreach.
  1. Maintain contemporaneous records
  • For business expenses, charitable gifts, and medical costs, keep receipts, mileage logs, and appointment records. The IRS accepts digital copies, but they must be legible and retained for the required period (generally three years, longer in some cases) (IRS Recordkeeping guidance).
  1. Be conservative and consistent with deductions
  • Claim only ordinary and necessary business expenses and use the simplified home‑office method or the actual‑expense method consistently and correctly. Avoid unusually large or repeated losses without supporting documentation or a clear business plan.
  1. Use bookkeeping tools and bank‑business separation
  • Keep business and personal accounts separate. Reliable accounting software reduces errors, produces audit‑ready reports, and helps when reconstructing activity for the IRS.
  1. Understand specific rules for sensitive items
  • Charitable donations: Obtain acknowledgment letters for gifts of $250+. For noncash gifts, use appraisals when required.
  • Vehicle and travel expenses: Keep mileage logs and contemporaneous notes on business purpose (Publication 463).
  • Virtual currency: Treat crypto transactions as property, report sales and exchanges, and keep transaction histories.
  1. File timely, and respond promptly to notices
  • Filing extensions when necessary avoids late penalties. If you receive IRS correspondence, respond by the stated deadline; prompt, factual replies often prevent escalation.
  1. Get professional help for complex situations
  • If you operate multiple entities, receive foreign income, or have large investments, work with a CPA or tax attorney familiar with current IRS enforcement priorities. In my work, proactive tax planning reduces surprises and audit exposure.

What to do if you’re selected for an audit

Recordkeeping timeline and retention

  • General rule: Keep tax records for at least three years after filing (the period in which the IRS typically audits). Keep records for seven years if you reported a loss from worthless securities or bad debt, and indefinitely for permanently owned assets where basis tracking matters. For guidance, consult IRS recordkeeping publications.

Common misconceptions and pitfalls

  • ‘‘I’m too small to be audited’’: Size alone isn’t a shield—mismatches and unusual deductions matter more.
  • ‘‘If I ignore the notice it will go away’’: Ignoring IRS notices can lead to default assessments, penalties, and enforced collection.
  • ‘‘Hiring a preparer guarantees safety’’: A paid preparer reduces errors but does not eliminate audit risk. Ensure your preparer follows best practices and signs the return.

Authoritative sources and further reading

  • IRS, Understanding IRS audits and notices (see IRS.gov)
  • IRS Publication 463 (Travel, Gift, and Car Expenses), Publication 526 (Charitable Contributions), Publication 587 (Business Use of Your Home)
  • IRS Data Book and audit selection summaries

Professional perspective and closing advice

In my experience as a CFP® and CPA advising taxpayers for over 15 years, the most common reason returns escalate is not intentional fraud but poor documentation and inconsistent reporting. The best strategy is preventive: reconcile income, keep clear receipts and logs, and be conservative and consistent when claiming deductions. When in doubt, document the business purpose and consult a qualified tax professional.

Legal disclaimer

This article is educational and does not constitute legal or tax advice. For advice tailored to your circumstances, consult a qualified tax professional or attorney.

Related FinHelp guides