How Do You Value a Business for Transfer or Sale?
Accurately valuing a business for transfer or sale matters for three reasons: it sets buyer and seller expectations, determines tax and estate consequences, and supports financing or negotiation. In practice, I’ve seen owners lose value by relying on a single method or weak documentation; combining approaches, documenting assumptions, and involving the right advisors produces the most defensible results.
Three primary valuation approaches
- Asset-based approach
- What it measures: Net value of tangible and identifiable intangible assets (assets minus liabilities).
- When it’s useful: Capital-intensive companies in liquidation or businesses with significant real estate/equipment.
- Key adjustments: Update book values to fair market value (FMV), capitalize or expense repairs, and separately value intangible assets (customer lists, trademarks).
- Income approach (Discounted Cash Flow and capitalization)
- What it measures: Present value of future economic benefits (cash flows or earnings).
- Methods: Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) for multi-year projections; capitalizing normalized earnings (SDE or EBITDA) for stable businesses.
- Critical inputs: Reliable historical financials, realistic revenue/expense projections, an appropriate discount or capitalization rate (reflecting business risk and prevailing interest rates).
- Market approach
- What it measures: Value implied by prices paid for comparable businesses (multiples of revenue, EBITDA, or SDE).
- When it’s useful: Active M&A markets with plenty of comparables (franchises, restaurants, professional practices).
- Limitations: Finding true comparables is often hard; adjustments for size, geography, and growth must be documented.
Most credible valuations blend approaches and reconcile differences rather than relying on a single line of evidence.
Practical steps to get a defensible valuation
- Assemble reliable records
Gather 3–5 years of financial statements (prepared or reviewed, not just tax returns), tax returns, cap tables, leases, major contracts, asset lists, and customer metrics (retention, concentration). Buyers and lenders will scrutinize these documents.
- Normalize earnings
Adjust owner compensation, one-time expenses, non-operating income, and discretionary benefits to show operating performance a typical buyer would get. For small owner-operated businesses, Seller’s Discretionary Earnings (SDE) is commonly used; for larger firms, use EBITDA.
- Choose and justify methods
Explain why you used asset, income, or market methods and how you weighted them. For example, lean on income methods for service businesses with strong recurring revenue; emphasize assets for real estate-heavy firms.
- Calculate and reconcile
Produce a valuation range rather than a single point estimate; reconcile differences and state key sensitivity assumptions (growth rates, discount rates, multiples). Buyers expect defensible assumptions.
- Document supporting workpapers
Retain the models, industry multiples, market transaction evidence, and a clear narrative to support each adjustment. This matters for tax reporting (e.g., Form 8594 for asset sales) and for any post-closing disputes.
Tax and transfer implications to consider
-
Asset sale vs. equity sale: Buyers prefer asset purchases (stepped-up basis), sellers typically prefer stock sales (potential capital gains treatment). Each structure has different tax timing and liability consequences—discuss with a tax advisor (see IRS guidance and Form 8594 for asset acquisitions).
-
Gift and estate transfers: Valuation discounts or minority-control discounts may apply to family transfers, but these are scrutinized by the IRS and require strong appraisals (see IRS Publication 561 and applicable revenue rulings).
-
Reporting and documentation: For meaningful transfers and sales, retain valuation reports and supporting documents in case of IRS questions. If the sale includes installment payments or earnouts, structure the agreement to reflect timing of recognition.
(Authoritative references: IRS Publication 561 on valuation of donated property and revenue rulings on valuation theory; IRS Form 8594 for asset acquisitions.)
Common valuation adjustments and traps
- Customer concentration: High concentration reduces enterprise value; price should reflect risk if a few customers drive most revenue.
- Key-person risk: Losing a founder or lead salesperson can materially reduce value; add a discount or require transition plans.
- Intangible assets: Recognize brand, trademarks, and proprietary processes—but only when you can quantify their economic contribution.
- Overstating growth: Buyers discount aggressive projections. Be conservative and show sensitivity analyses.
Negotiation mechanics and deal structures
- Earnouts: Use when future performance is uncertain. Clearly define metrics, measurement periods, caps, and dispute-resolution mechanisms (prefer independent accounting rules).
- Holdbacks/escrow: Protect buyers from undisclosed liabilities; sellers should negotiate decay schedules and clear earnout triggers.
- Warranties and reps: Limit exposure with reasonable survival periods and caps tied to deal size.
Who should be involved?
- Business valuation professional or accredited appraiser (e.g., ASA, CVA) for high‑stakes transactions.
- CPA or tax attorney to advise on tax structuring and reporting.
- M&A advisor or broker for market access and negotiation support.
- Lender or buyer’s financial analyst for due diligence.
In my practice I recommend starting the valuation and cleanup 12–18 months before an intended sale—this allows you to normalize earnings, fix accounting inconsistencies, and put transition agreements (key employees, leases) in place.
Common mistakes and how to avoid them
-
Relying only on tax returns: Tax returns are a baseline but often include owner compensation and tax-driven entries that misstate economic earnings. Normalize to operating results.
-
Failing to quantify intangible value: Simply saying “brand is valuable” won’t move market buyers. Tie intangible assets to measurable cash flows or cost savings.
-
Ignoring marketability and control discounts: For minority or non-marketable interests, apply discounts supported by market studies and precedent—especially in family transfers.
-
Weak documentation of assumptions: Document market multiples, peer transactions, and the source of discount rates. That paperwork matters for lenders, buyers, and the IRS.
Checklist before listing or transferring
- 3–5 years of financial statements and tax returns
- Updated asset listing with FMV adjustments
- Normalized earnings schedule and supporting adjustments
- Copies of key contracts, leases, and IP registrations
- Clear cap table and shareholder agreements
- Draft purchase agreement with proposed deal structure (asset vs. equity)
Links to related guidance on FinHelp
-
For tax-focused steps around valuation and reporting, see our guide: Tax Steps When Selling a Business: From Valuation to Reporting.
-
When transferring to family, valuation discounts and gifting strategies can apply—review: Valuation Discounts for Family Business Gifting.
Final notes and professional disclaimer
A defensible valuation is a blend of rigorous financial analysis, clear documentation, and practical negotiation strategy. Start early, use multiple approaches, and engage experienced appraisers and tax advisors.
This article is educational and not a substitute for personalized tax or legal advice. For transaction-specific planning, consult a qualified CPA, business appraiser, or attorney. Key authoritative sources include IRS Publication 561 and IRS materials on asset sales and Form 8594; consult the IRS and your tax advisor for the most current guidance.
(For general consumer protection resources, see the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau at consumerfinance.gov.)
