Value averaging is a systematic investment strategy that helps investors reach specific portfolio value goals by adjusting contributions according to market performance, unlike fixed-sum methods such as dollar-cost averaging. Conceived by Michael Edleson and detailed in his 1991 book “Value Averaging: The Safe and Easy Strategy for Higher Investment Returns,” this approach aims to optimize returns by buying more shares when prices are low and fewer when prices are high.

How Value Averaging Works

Value averaging involves setting a predetermined target for your portfolio’s value growth over regular intervals (monthly, quarterly, etc.). After each period, you calculate the difference between your actual portfolio value and the target. If your portfolio is below target, you invest additional funds to catch up. If your portfolio is above target, you invest less or sell assets to reduce the value back to your target. This dynamic adjustment helps you systematically buy low and sell high.

For example, if you plan to increase your portfolio by $100 monthly, starting at $0:

  • Month 1: Invest $100 to reach $100
  • Month 2: If portfolio value falls short (e.g., $80), invest $120 to meet the $200 target
  • Month 3: If portfolio exceeds target (e.g., $375), withdraw $75 to reset to $300

This disciplined method requires active monitoring and flexibility in contributions but can lead to improved returns in volatile markets.

Comparing Value Averaging and Dollar-Cost Averaging

Both strategies aim to mitigate the risks of investing a lump sum all at once, but they differ:

  • Value Averaging (VA): Contribution amounts vary, aiming to meet incremental portfolio value goals. It can require selling shares or withdrawing funds if the portfolio outperforms targets.
  • Dollar-Cost Averaging (DCA): Invests a fixed amount regularly regardless of market conditions, buying more shares when prices are low and fewer when high naturally.

You can learn more about dollar-cost averaging in our detailed article Dollar-Cost Averaging.

Who Should Consider Value Averaging?

Value averaging suits disciplined investors comfortable with monitoring their portfolios and adjusting contributions, especially those with flexible finances. It’s most effective over the long term with investments expected to grow but experience market fluctuations, such as stock index funds or ETFs. It’s less suitable for investors seeking a passive, set-it-and-forget-it approach or those with rigid budgets.

Practical Tips for Success

  • Start with a manageable investment or a low-cost index fund.
  • Set realistic incremental targets aligned with your financial capacity.
  • Maintain an emergency fund to cover possible higher contributions in downturns.
  • Be prepared to sell shares if needed to maintain your target value.
  • Monitor progress regularly and use simple tools like spreadsheets.
  • Consider using value averaging within tax-advantaged accounts to manage tax implications.

Common Misconceptions

  • Value averaging doesn’t guarantee higher returns or eliminate investment risk.
  • It’s not fully automated; active monitoring and adjustment are necessary.
  • You might need to sell shares, which contrasts with “buy and hold” habits.
  • It requires discipline but is accessible with basic understanding and commitment.

FAQs

  • Is value averaging better than dollar-cost averaging? It depends on your investment goals and willingness to actively manage your portfolio. VA can outperform in volatile markets but requires more effort.
  • Can I apply it in retirement accounts? Yes, especially in IRAs where contribution flexibility and tax benefits enhance VA’s effectiveness.
  • What if I can’t meet target contributions? Missing a month’s contribution requires recalculating your target path and resuming the plan without panic.
  • How often should I adjust? Monthly or quarterly checks are typical, balancing responsiveness and effort.
  • Is value averaging appropriate for all investments? Best suited for volatile investments like stocks; less effective for fixed-income or highly speculative assets.

Value averaging presents a strategic, flexible approach to investing that can take advantage of market fluctuations when applied with discipline and realistic planning.

Sources: