Overview

Valuation discounts adjust the fair market value of ownership interests to reflect economic features that make an interest worth less than a proportionate share of the underlying assets. The two most common discounts used in family transfers are:

  • Minority interest discounts (lack of control)
  • Lack-of-marketability discounts (longer sale horizon or limited buyers)

When applied appropriately, these discounts can reduce the taxable value reported on gift tax returns (Form 709) or influence estate tax calculations, helping families move wealth with greater tax efficiency. However, the IRS and tax courts require objective valuation support, documented business purpose, and appropriate legal structure; absence of those increases the risk of audit and adjustment (see IRS valuation guidance such as Rev. Rul. 59-60 and official estate/gift tax pages for background).

Sources: IRS valuation principles (Rev. Rul. 59-60), IRS — Estate and Gift Taxes.

Why discounts exist (valuation logic)

Two basic economic realities underlie discounts:

  1. Control vs. non-control. A controlling owner can make business decisions (hire/replace managers, set dividends, approve major transactions). A minority owner lacks those rights, so buyers pay less for a proportionate stake.

  2. Marketability. Interests that cannot be sold quickly, or only to a narrow set of buyers (for example, privately held company shares or closely held partnership units), are worth less than freely traded securities.

Appraisers incorporate these realities into a valuation by adjusting a baseline estimate of value (often derived from an income approach like discounted cash flow, or market approach using guideline companies) with discounts that reflect the above factors.

How discounts change tax outcomes (gift vs. estate timing)

  • Gift transfers: When you give an interest during life, the value of that gift is reported on Form 709. Applying valid valuation discounts lowers the reported gift amount and may reduce or eliminate gift tax liability in years where lifetime exemptions are exceeded. But remember: a gift carries the donor’s original cost basis, so recipients may inherit a low basis and potentially face larger capital gains taxes when they sell.

  • Transfer at death: Interests transferred at death are included in the decedent’s gross estate at fair market value as of the date of death (or alternate valuation date if applicable). In many cases, a step-up in basis to the date‑of‑death value applies for assets included in the estate — a key difference from lifetime gifting. Therefore, transferring interests before death to take advantage of discounts can trade lower near-term gift/estate taxes for lost basis step-up.

  • Built-in gains and tax trade-offs: If the asset has substantial unrealized appreciation, gifting a discounted interest removes the asset from the donor’s estate but preserves the donor’s basis – the recipient’s taxable gain on sale will be based on that carryover basis. Consider the interaction between valuation discounts and capital gains exposure when planning.

Common structures that use discounts

  • Family limited partnerships (FLPs) and family LLCs: These entities can centralize ownership of family assets and facilitate transfers of limited partnership or non-managing interest that often qualify for minority and marketability discounts. (See our explainer on Family Limited Partnerships for estate planning uses.)

  • Sales to intentionally defective grantor trusts or minority sales with promissory notes: These are more advanced techniques that require strict compliance and valuation support.

  • Transfers of non-controlling shares in closely held businesses and fractional interests in real estate or collectibles.

Internal links:

Valuation methods and supporting evidence

Qualified appraisers use one or more of the following approaches:

  • Income approach (discounted cash flow or capitalization of earnings): Projects future cash flows and converts to present value.
  • Market approach: Uses guideline public company multiples adjusted for size, liquidity, and differences in control.
  • Option-pricing and restricted stock studies: Statistical studies and models sometimes inform marketability discounts.

Supportive evidence includes recent transactions, company financials, operating agreements, surveys of buyers for similar interests, and documentation of restrictions that limit transferability. The IRS relies on objective, contemporaneous evidence — not unsupported percentages.

Authoritative references: Revenue Ruling 59-60 (factors to consider in valuing closely held businesses) and IRS guidance on estate and gift taxes.

Tax law constraints and IRS scrutiny

The IRS and courts will scrutinize discount claims for family transfers. Important legal constraints include:

  • IRC §2701 (special valuation rules): This provision can recharacterize certain family transfers of corporate interests that are structured to create artificial discounts by removing control rights; it reduces or eliminates discounts in many common family planning arrangements. (See Internal Revenue Code §2701.)

  • Substance over form scrutiny: The IRS looks for bona fide economic arrangements, proper governance, arms-length management, and real transfer of control where stated.

  • Shams and lack of business purpose: Transactions done solely for tax reduction without economic substance are at high risk of challenge and penalties.

Because of these limits, documented, independent appraisals and adherence to legal formalities are essential.

Typical discount ranges — and why you should treat them as heuristics

Published studies and practitioner surveys show wide variation in discounts depending on industry, size, governance restrictions, and market conditions. Typical ranges often cited in practice are:

  • Minority interest discounts: commonly 10%–40%, depending on the company and ownership percentage.
  • Lack-of-marketability discounts: commonly 15%–50% for interests with meaningful transfer restrictions.

These ranges are examples, not safe harbors. The correct discount for a particular transfer depends on detailed analysis by a qualified appraiser and legal review; courts have reversed unsupported blanket discounts.

Practical checklist before using discounts in a family transfer

  1. Obtain a current, independent business valuation from a credentialed appraiser (ASA, CFA with valuation specialty, or accredited valuation analyst).
  2. Document the business purpose for the entity structure and family transfers (succession, asset protection, centralized management).
  3. Follow formalities: partnership/LLC agreements, regular meetings, documented distributions, and arms‑length transactions.
  4. Review anti‑abuse rules such as IRC §2701 and confirm structuring won’t trigger recharacterization.
  5. File accurate tax returns (Form 709 for gifts). Keep appraisal reports and supporting evidence for at least the limitations period.

Common mistakes and red flags for auditors

  • Applying standardized discount percentages without valuation support.
  • Failing to keep corporate or partnership formalities.
  • Using discounts to hide transfer of control while retaining practical control.
  • Ignoring Section 2701 and similar anti‑avoidance rules.

Any of the above increases the odds of an adjustment, penalties, or a protracted valuation dispute.

Example (simplified)

A parent transfers a 10% noncontrolling interest in a closely held business appraised at $2,000,000 (for 100% of the company, so a 10% pro rata share would be $200,000). A qualified appraisal that supports a 25% minority and marketability discount reduces the taxable gift value to $150,000 (a $50,000 reduction). That reduction lowers the reported gift but does not change the parent’s basis in the underlying business, and could affect future capital gains when the child sells; further planning must weigh the benefit of removing value from the estate against lost basis step‑up at death.

This simplified example omits many real-world factors (promises to buy, buy‑sell agreements, voting rights, control premiums) that influence both economics and tax treatment.

When to involve specialists

In my practice over 15+ years working with families and closely held businesses, valuation discounts are one of the most potent tools when used correctly — but also one of the most litigated. I recommend assembling a team that includes:

  • A credentialed valuation professional experienced with family business valuations.
  • A tax attorney familiar with IRC §2701 and gift/estate planning issues.
  • A CPA who understands filing requirements and basis consequences.

Early coordination among these advisors reduces the chance of an adverse IRS challenge and helps structure transfers that meet both financial and family goals.

Bottom line

Valuation discounts can materially reduce gift and estate tax exposure in family transfers when supported by credible appraisals, sound legal structure, and documented economic purpose. They are not automatic or risk‑free: IRS anti‑abuse rules (such as IRC §2701), poor documentation, or sham structures can eliminate discounts and trigger adjustments and penalties. Use experienced appraisers and legal counsel, and weigh trade‑offs such as lost basis step‑up when deciding whether to transfer during life or at death.

Professional disclaimer

This article is educational and does not constitute legal, tax, or investment advice. Rules change and outcomes depend on facts. Consult a qualified tax attorney, CPA, or accredited appraiser before implementing valuation‑based transfer strategies.

Authoritative sources and further reading

  • IRS, “Estate and Gift Taxes” (overview), IRS.gov.
  • Revenue Ruling 59-60 (factors in valuing closely held businesses).
  • Internal Revenue Code §2701 (special valuation rules for certain transfers of interests in corporations and partnerships).

Further reading on related topics at FinHelp: