Why transcripts matter

IRS transcripts are the IRS’s record of what it received or recorded for your Social Security number. Unlike a copy of your filed return, transcripts include account actions (payments, penalties, adjustments) and income third parties reported — making them a primary piece of evidence when someone files a return using your identity.

Key transcript types and what to look for

  • Tax Return Transcript — summary of the return as filed. Use it to confirm the return’s filing status, dependents claimed, refunds or balances due.
  • Account Transcript — shows account activity: payments, assessments, penalties, and adjustments. Use it to spot unauthorized changes or amended returns.
  • Wage and Income Transcript — lists W‑2s, 1099s and other third‑party income reported under your SSN. This is often the clearest proof of phantom wages or a different employer filing under your number.

How to obtain transcripts (safe, official routes)

  1. Start at the IRS Get Transcript page and choose the method that fits you — Get Transcript Online (instant PDF after identity verification) or Get Transcript by Mail. See: https://www.irs.gov/individuals/get-transcript (IRS).
  2. If you can’t use online tools, the IRS provides alternative request options on the same page.
  3. Save PDFs, print dated copies, and note the retrieval method (online vs. mailed copy). Treat them as preserved evidence.

Step‑by‑step: use transcripts to detect identity theft

  1. Order the Tax Return, Account, and Wage & Income transcripts for the tax years in question.
  2. Compare wage and income lines to your W‑2s, 1099s, payroll stubs, and bank deposits. Flag any unfamiliar employer names, unexpected 1099 payers, or income amounts you didn’t receive.
  3. Check the Account Transcript for unexpected adjustments, amended returns, or refunds you didn’t authorize.
  4. Look for duplicate filings — two returns filed for the same year or a refund issued when you didn’t file.

How to use transcripts to prove identity theft (evidence chain)

  • Preserve originals and dated copies of all transcripts. Transcripts carry IRS retrieval dates and are considered authoritative records.
  • Assemble supporting evidence: your actual W‑2/1099s, pay stubs, employer statements denying the employment, and bank records showing you did not receive the refund.
  • Report to the FTC at https://www.identitytheft.gov and create an identity‑theft recovery plan. File a police report with the transcript and supporting docs attached; the police report helps with creditors and some IRS processes.
  • Submit the IRS identity‑theft claim process as directed on IRS Identity Theft Central (https://www.irs.gov/identity-theft-fraud-scams). The IRS may ask you to complete Form 14039 (Identity Theft Affidavit) or follow specific notice instructions.
  • Keep a written log of all calls (date, time, agent name, and next steps) when you contact the IRS or other agencies.

What to expect and timing

  • The IRS sometimes places an Identity Theft Indicator on an account. Resolution can take weeks to months depending on complexity.
  • If identity theft prevented e‑filing, the IRS may require you to mail a paper return or verify your identity before processing. Request an Identity Protection PIN (IP PIN) once your case is handled to prevent future fraudulent e‑filings.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Waiting too long to request transcripts; early detection reduces damage.
  • Assuming an IRS notice will automatically mean resolution — you must follow the IRS’s steps and document your communications.
  • Discarding transcript copies or failing to gather corroborating documents (pay stubs, employer statements, bank records).

Professional tips

  • Order wage and income transcripts for the range of years when you suspect the theft — most issues show up when a criminal files wage‑based returns using your SSN.
  • Use the online transcript tool when possible: it provides immediate PDFs and shows retrieval time, useful in disputes.
  • Keep a secure, dated folder (digital and paper) for all identity‑theft evidence.

Related resources on FinHelp

When to call a pro

If transcripts reveal complex or repeated fraud (multiple years, multiple employers, or an unexpected amended return), contact a tax professional experienced in identity‑theft resolution or a tax attorney. In my practice, early engagement with the IRS and a complete transcript packet shortens dispute timelines and prevents reoccurrence.

What this article does — and doesn’t — cover

This article explains how to use IRS transcripts to detect and document tax‑related identity theft. It is educational and does not replace personalized legal or tax advice. For case‑specific guidance, consult a licensed tax professional or attorney.

Authoritative sources