Subsurface Rights Impact on Lending

How Do Subsurface Rights Affect Mortgage Approval and Lending?

Subsurface rights, or mineral rights, grant ownership of the resources beneath a property’s surface separately from the land itself. These rights may be sold or leased independently, creating risks for lenders concerned about potential damage, decreased property value, and legal issues, which can influence mortgage eligibility.
Visual representation of subsurface mineral rights impacting property value for lending purposes

When buying a home, understanding subsurface rights is crucial because these rights govern ownership of natural resources like oil, gas, or minerals lying beneath your property. Unlike surface rights, which cover the land and structures on it, subsurface rights can be owned separately — a situation called “split estate.” This separation often occurs in states with mining or drilling histories, including Texas, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, and Colorado.

Lenders view your home as collateral for a mortgage loan. If subsurface rights are owned by another party, they may exercise their right to extract minerals by accessing the surface, potentially causing property damage, noise, environmental issues, or disruptions. These factors can reduce the property’s market value, complicate resale, and increase legal risks, making lenders cautious.

Mortgage programs such as Conventional loans (Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac), FHA, VA, and USDA loans handle subsurface rights differently:

  • Conventional Loans require confirmation that mineral extraction won’t significantly harm property value or use, often satisfied through a Surface Use Agreement (SUA), which limits drilling activities.
  • FHA Loans have stricter rules disallowing properties near active or planned drilling sites to protect occupant health and safety (per HUD Handbook 4000.1).
  • VA Loans rely on appraisals to ensure mineral rights issues don’t negatively affect property value or usability.
  • USDA Loans may exclude properties with unrestricted mineral rights access by others due to risk concerns.

If you face subsurface rights issues, it’s essential to:

  • Consult a specialized attorney in mineral rights to understand agreements and risks.
  • Review the title report closely for mineral rights ownership details (see also Title Binder).
  • Seek a Surface Use Agreement to limit drilling impact.
  • Discuss the situation early with your lender to understand loan eligibility and documentation requirements.

For more on mortgages and loan types, and how property issues can influence lending, explore our related guides.

Sources:

For official guidance, visit HUD.gov and FannieMae.com.

Recommended for You

Appraisal Contingency Waiver

An appraisal contingency waiver means a homebuyer agrees to proceed with a purchase even if the home's appraised value is less than the offer price, eliminating a key financial safety net.
Learn more about Appraisal Contingency Waiver

Transfer Tax Disclosure

A Transfer Tax Disclosure is a signed document in real estate that identifies the final sale price and specifies which party pays the property transfer tax, helping avoid confusion at closing.
Learn more about Transfer Tax Disclosure

Gift of Equity

A gift of equity allows a family member to sell a home below market value, enabling the buyer to use the difference as a down payment without needing cash upfront.
Learn more about Gift of Equity

Prepaid Title Insurance

Prepaid title insurance is a one-time fee paid at closing to secure protection against past title defects that could threaten your property ownership or mortgage lender’s interest.
Learn more about Prepaid Title Insurance

Investment Property Mortgage

An investment property mortgage is a loan specifically for purchasing rental properties. These mortgages have stricter requirements, higher down payments, and increased interest rates compared to loans for primary residences.
Learn more about Investment Property Mortgage
View All Glossary