How do state residency tests determine your tax obligations after a move?
Moving between states can change where you owe state income tax. States decide residency with a mix of objective and subjective tests: days in the state (statutory tests), and connections or intent (common-law or domicile tests). The result determines whether you file as a resident, part-year resident, or nonresident and whether the state taxes all or only in-state income.
Below I summarize practical steps, real examples from my practice, documentation to keep, common pitfalls, and how to respond if a state challenges your claimed residency.
How residency tests work (statutory vs. common-law)
- Statutory residency: Many states use a bright-line days test—commonly 183 days—as a trigger. If you exceed the threshold and maintain a place to live, some states will treat you as a resident for tax purposes regardless of your intent.
- Common-law / domicile: Other tests focus on where you intend to make your permanent home (domicile). States analyze facts such as where you own or rent a home, where your family lives, voter registration, driver’s license, vehicle registration, and where you spend most of your time.
Note: Exact rules differ by state. For example, New York applies a combination of a permanent place of abode test plus the 183-day rule; other states have statutory-resident rules or multiple-factor domicile inquiries. Always check the relevant state revenue department guidance for the state(s) involved.
Authoritative sources and general guidance: Internal Revenue Service (IRS) and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau provide general guidance on residency concepts and tax obligations; for state-specific rules consult that state’s department of revenue or taxation website.
- IRS general site: https://www.irs.gov
- Consumer guidance: https://www.consumerfinance.gov
Why it matters: tax consequences of changing residency
- Taxable income scope: Residents generally pay state tax on all income (worldwide), while nonresidents usually pay only on income sourced to the state.
- Dual/state credits: If two states claim you were a resident, you may face overlapping tax bills. Many states offer credits for taxes paid to another state, but credits won’t always eliminate double taxation.
- Withholding and estimated tax: Your employer may withhold state tax based on your work and residency. If you change residency mid-year, you might need to update withholding or pay estimated taxes to avoid penalties.
In my practice I’ve seen midyear movers who didn’t update withholding and later faced tax due plus penalties on state returns. Being proactive prevents these surprises.
Concrete steps to establish residency (and document it)
- Change your primary address everywhere that matters: driver’s license, voter registration, bank accounts, and tax forms (W-4 state equivalents). Keep confirmation receipts or screenshots.
- Lease/purchase primary residence: A signed lease or deed is powerful evidence of a new domicile.
- Move family, dependents, and personal effects: Where you and your immediate family live most of the year matters.
- Update registrations and licenses: Driver’s license, vehicle title, professional licenses, and voter registration.
- Re-route mail and update healthcare providers: Change mailing addresses for banks, insurance, physicians, and subscription services.
- Establish community ties: Join local clubs, church, or professional organizations; get local health care and dentist; register children in local schools.
- Keep a day-by-day log: Record travel with dates, reasons for trips, and locations. During audits, contemporaneous records are more persuasive than reconstructed calendars.
Documentation checklist to keep (digital + paper):
- Lease/deed and closing statements
- Driver’s license and vehicle registration
- Voter registration card
- Utility bills showing occupancy dates
- Job offer letters, paystubs, and employer correspondence
- Bank statements and mailed statements showing the new address
- Day-by-day travel log (purpose and location)
Example scenarios from practice
1) The remote-worker shift: A software engineer moved from California to Texas and assumed living in Texas for tax purposes. He had a lease, TX driver’s license, and voted in Texas, but kept a rental in California and periodically returned for client meetings. Because California applies aggressive residency rules, we tracked his days in California carefully, limited ties there, and documented Texas connections. Outcome: substantiated Texas residency and reduced California exposure, but required careful recordkeeping.
2) The snowbird: A retiree split time between Massachusetts (primary residence) and Florida (winter home). The retiree had to show intent and permanent ties to Florida (driver’s license, sold MA vehicle, moved mail, and listed FL as domicile on federal records). Small oversights—like failing to register to vote in Florida—can weaken the domicile claim.
These examples show that intent plus consistent actions matter. One strong act (e.g., license and voting) plus supporting facts is better than a paper address change alone.
Common mistakes and how to avoid them
- Mistake: Only changing your mailing address. Avoid by changing licenses, voter registration, and financial accounts.
- Mistake: Not keeping a contemporaneous day log of travel. Maintain a simple calendar with dates and reasons for trips.
- Mistake: Keeping too many ties to the old state (membership, subscriptions, frequent stays). Reduce or document necessity of those ties.
- Mistake: Ignoring employer withholding. Tell payroll your new state so withholding matches your new status.
Special situations
-
Remote work and multistate withholding: If you live in one state and your employer is in another, you may face withholding in both states. Check any reciprocal tax agreements between states and consult payroll to correct withholding. See our guide on remote workers for deeper guidance: Remote Work and State Residency: Avoiding Multistate Tax Surprises.
-
Seasonal migrants (snowbirds): Many retirees try to switch domicile to a no-income-tax state (e.g., Florida, Texas). States look for clear acts showing intent to abandon the old domicile. See our practical steps in State Residency Planning for Seasonal Migrants (Snowbirds).
-
Amending returns and audits: If you discover you were a resident of the old state for part of the year, you may need to file part-year or nonresident returns and possibly amend prior filings. For how to stay compliant after a move, see: How to Stay Compliant When Changing State Residency for Tax Purposes.
What to do if a state challenges your residency
- Gather documentation: all items in the checklist above.
- Produce contemporaneous travel logs and proof of new-state ties.
- Consider a voluntary disclosure or amended returns when appropriate.
- If you get a tax notice, respond on time and request additional time if needed to assemble records.
- Consult a tax attorney or CPA experienced in multistate audits for representation if the assessment is substantial.
States may use audits to collect back taxes, interest, and penalties. Prompt, organized responses reduce exposure and often shorten the audit timeline.
Practical tips I give clients
- Start early: Begin changing documents and habits before or immediately after your move.
- Reduce conflicting ties: Avoid keeping strong, unnecessary ties to the old state when you want to change domicile.
- Be consistent: Your actions should match your claimed intent—don’t say one thing and do another.
- Use contemporaneous records: Keep receipts, bills, and a trip log.
- Get professional help for complex situations: High-income earners, business owners, or those with multiple homes often need tailored planning.
Frequently asked questions
Q: Can I be a resident of two states?
A: Yes, but it creates a complex filing situation and potential double taxation. Many states offer credits, but you should plan to minimize overlap.
Q: Does changing my driver’s license alone establish residency?
A: It’s a strong piece of evidence, but by itself it may not be enough. States look at the totality of the facts.
Q: How many days can I spend in my old state and still be considered a nonresident?
A: It depends on the state. The 183-day rule is common, but many states use multi-factor tests; check the state revenue guidance.
Final checklist before you move (1–2 weeks before and after)
- Obtain new driver’s license and register to vote in the new state.
- Change primary mailing address for banks, IRS, and benefits.
- Execute a lease or complete a home purchase and keep paperwork.
- Update employer payroll and withholding information.
- Move personal effects and family to the new address; document timing.
- Start a day-by-day log of state travel.
Professional disclaimer: This article is educational and not individualized tax advice. State residency rules are fact-specific and change over time. Consult a qualified tax professional or attorney for advice on your personal situation. For general federal guidance visit the IRS at https://www.irs.gov.
Sources and further reading:
- Internal Revenue Service (IRS): https://www.irs.gov
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau: https://www.consumerfinance.gov
- State revenue department guidance (search the specific state for current rules)
If you want, I can review a list of your ties and travel dates and suggest the strongest documentation to support a domicile change.
