Overview

An IRS CP2000 notice compares income the IRS received from third parties (Forms 1099) with what you reported. If a payer issues an amended 1099 after you filed, the IRS’s automated systems can produce a CP2000 proposing additional tax or a refund reversal. The notice gives a deadline (usually 30 days) to agree or disagree and provide documentation (IRS guidance: https://www.irs.gov/individuals/understanding-your-cp2000-notice).

Quick action steps (in order)

  1. Read the CP2000 carefully — note the tax year, the specific income items, and the response deadline printed on the notice.
  2. Compare the CP2000’s amounts with the original 1099, the amended 1099, and your bank / brokerage statements or invoices.
  3. Contact the payer if the amended 1099 looks wrong. Ask for a corrected form and a written explanation.
  4. Decide whether to agree (pay the proposed amount) or disagree (send a written explanation plus proof). If you agree and owe tax, pay as instructed to limit interest.
  5. If you need to change your return, prepare and file an amended return (Form 1040-X) with supporting attachments.

Documentation checklist

  • The original and amended 1099s (copies).
  • Year-end brokerage or bank statements showing dates and amounts.
  • Contracts, invoices, or payment confirmations that prove the correct income.
  • A short written explanation showing how you computed the amount on your return.
  • If you file Form 1040-X, include schedules and a copy of the amended 1099.

How to respond when the amended 1099 reduces reported income

  • If the amended 1099 shows less income than the amount you reported, you can:
    • File Form 1040-X to claim a refund (if applicable), attaching the amended 1099 and supporting records; or
    • Send the amended 1099 and evidence to the IRS with your CP2000 response if that resolves the discrepancy without amending.
  • In my practice, sending clear, dated statements and the payer’s correction often closes the case faster than filing a 1040-X, but filing an amended return is the right move when claiming a refund.

How to respond when the amended 1099 increases reported income

  • If the amended form increases income, you generally must either agree and pay the additional tax or disagree with documentation.
  • If you agree, pay as soon as possible or set up a payment arrangement to reduce interest and penalties.
  • If you disagree, provide bank/broker records or contracts showing the correct amount and a short cover letter explaining the discrepancy.

What to include in your written response

  • A one-page cover letter summarizing your position (agree or disagree).
  • Copies of the original and amended 1099(s).
  • Supporting documents (statements, invoices, settlement confirmations).
  • If filing Form 1040-X, include the amended schedules and math showing corrected tax.

Deadlines, penalties, and interest

  • CP2000 responses usually require action within about 30 days (check your notice for the exact date).
  • If you owe tax, interest starts accruing from the original due date of the tax return; penalties may also apply.
  • Paying the proposed tax or arranging payment promptly minimizes additional charges.

When to involve a tax pro or appeal

  • Hire a CPA, enrolled agent, or tax attorney if the amounts are large, the facts are complex, or you face proposed penalties.
  • If you disagree after submitting documentation and the IRS still adjusts your account, you can request an appeal or contact the IRS Appeals Office (see the CP2000 notice instructions and appeals info on IRS.gov).

Practical tips from practice

  • Keep a digital folder for each tax year with 1099s, bank/broker statements, and contracts — it saves time if a payer amends a form.
  • When a payer issues an amended 1099, request a brief explanation in writing; that note is persuasive to the IRS.
  • Don’t ignore the notice: in my 15 years as a CPA I’ve seen ignored CP2000s turn into larger balances with penalties and longer disputes.

Related resources on FinHelp

Authoritative sources

Professional disclaimer

This article is educational and not personalized tax advice. For guidance tailored to your situation, consult a licensed tax professional or CPA.