Overview

Information return penalties are assessed by the IRS when payers (employers, businesses, nonprofits, and others) fail to meet legal requirements for filing forms such as W-2 and the various 1099 series. These penalties are calculated per form and per recipient and can become a material expense for small businesses that miss deadlines or submit inaccurate returns. Because information returns are used by the IRS to cross-check income reported by taxpayers, these forms carry compliance importance beyond mere paperwork (see IRS information returns guidance: https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employed/information-returns).

In my work advising small-business owners and nonprofit treasurers, I’ve seen a single missed 1099 or mismatched W-2 trigger multiple notices and unexpected cash outflows. The goal of this article is practical: explain how penalties arise, show proven ways to avoid them, and give step-by-step next actions if you receive a notice.

How do information return penalties work?

  • Who pays: The filer (business or payer) is responsible for sending correct information returns to both the IRS and the payee.
  • How penalties are assessed: Penalties are generally assessed per form when a required return is late, missing, or contains inaccurate information. The IRS publishes the specific penalty schedule and adjusts amounts for inflation; always check the current amounts on the IRS penalties page (https://www.irs.gov/compliance/enforcement/penalties).
  • Common triggers: missed deadlines, incorrect taxpayer identification numbers (TINs), missing payee names or addresses, and filing a form to the IRS that’s different from the copy given to the payee.

Note: penalty amounts and thresholds are updated periodically. For exact, up-to-date dollar figures and filing rules, consult the IRS pages for the forms you file (W-2 information: https://www.irs.gov/forms-pubs/about-form-w-2; 1099 guidance: https://www.irs.gov/forms-pubs/about-form-1099).

Types of information return penalties and typical causes

  1. Late filing or failure to file: The filer misses the due date or does not file a required form at all. This is the most common cause.
  2. Incorrect or incomplete forms: Errors include wrong TINs, transposed numbers, incorrect amounts, or missing required boxes. Even seemingly minor errors can cause the IRS to flag a return.
  3. Failure to furnish a correct payee statement: If the recipient’s copy (for example, the contractor’s 1099-NEC) is not delivered or is incorrect, a penalty can apply separately from the IRS filing penalty.
  4. Electronic filing failures: If you must e-file and fail to do so (or submit invalid files), penalties may apply.

Real numbers and how to verify them

Because the IRS adjusts penalty amounts over time, I do not list fixed dollar amounts here. Instead, treat the penalty rules as a three-tier structure (short-delay, medium-delay, long-delay/no-file), then confirm the exact per-form penalty amount on the IRS penalty page: https://www.irs.gov/compliance/enforcement/penalties. That said, historically the IRS has used a tiered approach (smaller penalty for filings corrected within 30 days, a larger penalty if filed by a later date such as August 1, and the largest penalty for filings after that or not filed at all). Always use the IRS page for the specific tax year you are filing for when calculating exposure.

Common mistakes that lead to penalties (real-world patterns)

  • Not collecting a completed Form W-9 before paying a contractor. Missing or incorrect TINs create downstream penalty exposure.
  • Misclassifying workers. Treating an employee as a contractor (or vice versa) can create both withholding issues and information return mismatches.
  • Cutting corners with manual processes late in the season—data entry mistakes spike when staff are rushing to meet January deadlines.
  • Using outdated payee information: payments to entities that have changed names or TINs often produce IRS mismatch notices.

In my practice, the single most common root cause is weak year-round recordkeeping. Staying organized avoids rushing in January and reduces errors.

Step-by-step plan to avoid penalties

  1. Collect and verify TINs at onboarding: Require a completed Form W-9 from every contractor and vendor before you pay. Verify TINs online with IRS TIN-matching if you file many returns.
  2. Use accounting software and reconcile regularly: Post payments to a dedicated accounts-payable or contractor-payments category so year-end reports are a simple export.
  3. Build deadline reminders and a filing calendar: Note the due dates for furnishing payee copies and for IRS filing (federal deadlines can change—confirm each year). Many filers treat January 31 as the key date for furnishing payee copies, but confirm for the specific form and tax year.
  4. Validate data before submission: Match payee names to TINs exactly. Small discrepancies in punctuation or suffixes may cause automated IRS mismatch notices.
  5. File corrected returns promptly when errors are found: Corrected forms reduce potential penalties or may qualify for reduced penalties in some cases.
  6. Consider e-filing and use approved formats: Bulk e-file reduces processing errors and can be required at certain thresholds.
  7. Consult a CPA or tax attorney if unsure: Classification or unusual payments (e.g., prizes, barter, nonemployee compensation) can have nuanced reporting requirements.

Practical tools I recommend: a central W-9 folder (digital), automated reminders tied to your payroll or AP system, and using a TIN verification service when you onboard new vendors.

Checklist before filing

  • Do you have a W-9 for every contractor or vendor paid during the year? If not, request one and document your attempts.
  • Have you reconciled contractor pay totals to your general ledger and bank statements?
  • Have you run a TIN/name match (manually or via IRS TIN-matching) for high-volume filers?
  • Did you prepare payee copies and the IRS/transmittal copies in the correct format (paper vs. e-file)?
  • If you found errors, did you prepare corrected returns and send corrected payee statements?

What to do if you receive a penalty notice

  1. Read the notice carefully and note the forms, payees, and tax years involved.
  2. Confirm whether the penalty is for late filing, incorrect filing, or failure to furnish payee statements.
  3. Gather documentation showing timely efforts to comply (e.g., proof of filing, W-9 requests, software exports).
  4. Consider requesting penalty abatement. The IRS may grant relief for reasonable cause if you can show circumstances beyond your control (illness, natural disaster, reliance on incorrect professional advice, etc.). See IRS guidance on penalties and relief: https://www.irs.gov/compliance/enforcement/penalties.
  5. Respond on time. Ignoring notices typically increases penalties and interest.

In many cases I’ve handled, a well-documented abatement request with a reasonable-cause narrative and supporting records leads to partial or full relief. However, abatement is not guaranteed—prevention is the best strategy.

When to consult a professional

  • Reclassification questions: If you’re unsure whether someone is an employee or independent contractor, consult a CPA or employment-law attorney before the end of the year.
  • Large-volume or complex filings: High-volume filers should use bulk e-file services and consider professional review.
  • After receiving an IRS notice: Professional representation speeds resolution and avoids escalation.

Related reading on FinHelp

Frequently asked questions

Q: Can penalties be removed?
A: Yes, in some cases. The IRS may abate penalties for reasonable cause with adequate documentation. There is also limited administrative relief available in certain disaster or pandemic-related situations—check current IRS guidance.

Q: Who is responsible for penalties if a payroll provider files incorrectly?
A: The filer of record (your business) is generally responsible. If you hire a third party, use written service agreements and keep records showing the provider’s actions.

Q: Does timely mailing count as timely filing?
A: For paper filings, the IRS follows its published rules. For many modern returns, e-filing is required or preferred; confirm the filing method and deadlines each year.

Final tips and professional takeaway

  • Treat information returns as a year-round compliance task, not a last-minute chore.
  • Invest time in collecting W-9s and establishing simple internal checks—these small steps often prevent expensive penalties.
  • When in doubt, verify current penalty amounts and filing rules on IRS.gov and consult a tax professional to reduce your exposure.

Professional disclaimer: This article is educational and does not substitute for personalized tax advice. For guidance specific to your situation, consult a licensed CPA or tax attorney.

Authoritative resources: