Why consider alternative assets now?

Alternative assets have moved from institutional-only domains into options accessible to a wider set of investors through REITs, ETFs, crowdfunding platforms, private funds, and self-directed retirement accounts. These investments can lower overall portfolio volatility and offer unique return drivers that aren’t tied directly to public equity markets. That potential benefit comes with trade-offs: higher fees, limited liquidity, specialized due diligence, and different tax rules (for example, unrelated business taxable income in retirement accounts) — so a cautious, plan-driven approach is essential.

(For an overview of other ways to diversify beyond stocks and bonds, see Diversification Beyond Stocks and Bonds: Alternatives to Consider.)

How do alternative assets fit into an overall allocation?

Think of alternatives as a complement rather than a replacement for stocks and bonds. A practical framework I use with clients is:

  • Strategic allocation range: 5–20% of total investable assets for most retail investors. Use a smaller allocation (5–10%) if you need liquidity or are closer to retirement; consider larger allocations (10–20%) if you have a long horizon and higher risk tolerance.
  • Role-based placement: Decide whether an alternative is being used for income (e.g., income-producing real estate, REITs), growth (private equity), inflation protection (commodities), or diversification/risk management (hedge funds, certain real assets).
  • Liquidity bucket: Maintain emergency savings and liquid bond holdings to avoid being forced to sell illiquid alternatives in a downturn.

These are guidelines, not prescriptions. Your individual plan should reflect goals, timeline, tax situation, and risk tolerance.

Types of alternative assets and what to watch for

  • Real estate (direct property, REITs, real estate crowdfunding)

  • Benefits: potential cash flow, appreciation, and inflation hedge.

  • Risks: local market cycles, property management and maintenance, illiquidity for direct holdings.

  • Tax points: Real estate in IRAs or 401(k)s is possible in self-directed accounts but watch for unrelated business taxable income (UBTI/UBIT) and prohibited transactions (IRS). See IRS guidance on UBTI for retirement plans.

  • Private equity and venture capital

  • Benefits: access to early-stage growth and the potential for outsized returns.

  • Risks: long lock-ups (7–10+ years), high failure rates among startups, and concentrated exposure.

  • Access: often limited to accredited investors or institutional channels per SEC rules; publicly available vehicles (interval funds, business development companies) provide alternatives with different fee and liquidity profiles (SEC / FINRA).

  • Hedge funds and alternative active strategies

  • Benefits: strategies designed to produce absolute returns or hedge market stress.

  • Risks: high fees, strategy opacity, leverage risk, and manager dependence.

  • Commodities (physical metals, commodity futures, commodity ETFs)

  • Benefits: inflation hedges, diversification when supply shocks occur.

  • Risks: high price volatility, roll costs in futures-based funds.

  • Collectibles and tangible assets (art, antiques, rare coins)

  • Benefits: emotional utility and potential for appreciation.

  • Risks: valuation subjectivity, high transaction costs, storage and authenticity issues; often illiquid.

  • Alternative income sources (REITs, infrastructure funds)

  • Benefits: steady yield in a low-yield environment.

  • Risks: yield compression, interest-rate sensitivity, and fund-level leverage.

Due diligence and operational checklist

Before you invest, run a consistent checklist:

  1. Legal and structural review: Understand vehicle type (private fund, REIT, direct ownership) and investor protections. Confirm accreditation requirements, transfer restrictions, and redemption terms. (See SEC and FINRA investor resources.)
  2. Fees and expenses: Compare management and performance fees, acquisition and disposition costs, and platform fees. High fees can materially reduce net returns over time.
  3. Liquidity and lock-up terms: Know your redemption schedule, gates, or lock-up periods. Match illiquid investments with money you won’t need in the near term.
  4. Tax treatment: Check how distributions are taxed and whether the vehicle creates UBTI or taxable events in retirement accounts. Consult IRS guidance on retirement accounts and taxation of investment income.
  5. Manager experience and track record: Evaluate people and process—strategy performance through multiple cycles, not just through a bull market.
  6. Concentration risk: Avoid putting too large a portion of your net worth into a single alternative or manager.
  7. Exit and valuation mechanisms: Understand how holdings are appraised and how you exit the position.

In my practice, I insist on documented investment theses and stress‑test scenarios before introducing private or illiquid alternatives to a client’s portfolio.

Tax and retirement-account considerations

Alternative assets have particular tax implications you must plan for:

  • Retirement accounts: Self-directed IRAs and some 401(k) plans can hold alternative assets, but they’re subject to rules on prohibited transactions and may trigger unrelated business taxable income (UBTI), which can create current tax liabilities inside the IRA (IRS guidance on UBTI/UBIT).
  • Ordinary income vs. capital gains: Some proceeds (like collectibles or nonqualified dividends) are taxed differently—check the fund or vehicle prospectus and get tax counsel as needed.
  • Depreciation recapture and passive activity rules: Real estate can produce tax deductions (depreciation) and later recapture; passive-loss rules can limit the use of some property losses.

Always coordinate with a tax advisor before moving significant illiquid or leveraged alternative holdings into tax‑advantaged accounts.

Practical allocation examples (illustrative only)

  • Conservative tilt (near retirement): 5% alternatives split between public REIT ETFs and Treasury‑inflation protected holdings; prioritize liquidity and lower fees.
  • Growth orientation (long horizon): 10–15% alternatives, mixing private equity or VC funds (small allocation), REITs, and a commodities/precious metals allocation as an inflation hedge.
  • Income focus: 10% in diversified income-producing real assets (REITs, infrastructure funds) with the rest in bonds and dividend equities.

These examples are starting points; client-specific analysis will shift the mix.

Common mistakes I see and how to avoid them

  • Jumping in after good recent performance: Past performance, especially in private markets, can be survivorship biased.
  • Underestimating total cost: Fees, carried interest, and transaction costs often eat a larger share of returns than investors expect.
  • Misstating liquidity needs: Investing money you may need within a few years into long‑lock private deals often forces suboptimal sales.
  • Skipping tax planning: Bringing illiquid assets into IRAs or gifting them without tax planning can create traps.

Avoid these by getting written disclosure documents, asking for modeled returns (net of fees), and consulting both a fiduciary advisor and a tax pro.

Monitoring and rebalancing

Treat alternatives the same as traditional assets: set target allocations, rebalance periodically, and monitor manager performance. Because many alternatives are infrequently priced, rebalance by tolerance bands (e.g., rebalance if allocation drifts +/- 3–5 percentage points) or on a calendar cadence suited to the investments’ liquidity.

Where to find alternatives and safer access paths

  • Publicly traded proxies: REIT ETFs, commodity ETFs, and closed-end funds provide easier access with daily liquidity and clearer tax reporting.
  • Interval and tender-offer funds: Offer limited liquidity windows and exposure to private assets with ongoing share pricing.
  • Crowdfunding and digital platforms: Lower minimums but require careful vetting of sponsors and fee structures.
  • Private fund offerings: Offer direct exposure but usually have high minimums and accreditation thresholds per SEC rules. See FINRA and SEC resources for guidance on private placements.

(For guidance on deciding where to hold different asset types, see Asset Location Strategies: Where to Hold Stocks, Bonds, and Alternatives.)

Useful resources and next steps

  • SEC/Investor.gov — investor education on private placements and alternative investments (SEC).
  • FINRA — alerts and checklists for due diligence on private funds (FINRA).
  • IRS — guidance on unrelated business taxable income (UBTI) and retirement-account rules (IRS).
  • Consumer-focused guides from the CFPB may help with understanding fees and consumer protections when using new platforms.

If you’re considering introducing alternative assets to your portfolio, start with a written plan that states goals, time horizon, and maximum allocation. In my practice, I run a scenario analysis (best/worst/likely) and insist clients keep a 6–12 month cash reserve before adding illiquid alternatives.

Internal articles for further reading

Professional disclaimer

This article is educational and does not constitute individualized investment, tax, or legal advice. Contact a qualified financial planner, tax advisor, or attorney to review your personal situation before making investment decisions.

Author note (experience)

Over 15 years advising individual and institutional clients, I’ve used modest allocations to alternative assets to diversify portfolios, but I’ve also seen poorly structured private deals and overpriced platforms erode returns—so conservative vetting is nonnegotiable.

Selected authoritative sources