How the IRS finds non‑filers and why automated collections start

The IRS relies heavily on third‑party reporting and automated matching to spot people who haven’t filed required returns. Employers, banks, brokers, and government agencies submit information returns (W‑2s, 1099 series, Social Security statements, etc.). IRS computer systems compare that incoming data to the returns the agency has on file. When income is reported but no return exists, the account is flagged for follow‑up and often moves into the IRS automated collections workflow (ACS).

Automated collections are not “one person in a call center” — they are rules‑based processes designed to scale enforcement. They generate routine notices, can produce a Substitute for Return (SFR) or an assessment based on the third‑party data, and will escalate to liens or levies when taxpayers ignore multiple notices or fail to make payment arrangements. These automated steps protect the government’s ability to collect revenue, but they often produce results that are higher than what a careful, taxpayer‑prepared return would show. (IRS: Third‑party information and collection processes.)

Why substitute returns and assessments are risky

If you don’t file, the IRS can prepare a return for you under IRC 6020(b). This is commonly called a Substitute for Return (SFR). The IRS uses the information it has — W‑2s, 1099s, and other reports — to compute taxable income and tax due. An SFR will not include deductions, credits, or adjustments a taxpayer might claim, so the assessed tax is frequently larger than what the taxpayer actually owes.

Once an assessment is made, interest and penalties start immediately. Two common penalties are failure‑to‑file and failure‑to‑pay. Current penalty structure (as published by the IRS) generally applies a failure‑to‑file penalty that accrues monthly up to a statutory cap and a separate failure‑to‑pay penalty plus interest on unpaid tax. Because SFRs often produce inflated liabilities, those penalties and interest can compound quickly. (See IRS pages on penalties and interest.)

Typical automated notice and escalation path

Automated systems generate a sequence of notices and actions designed to move a case from notice to collection. While exact notice codes and timing can vary, the general path is:

  • Data match flags missing returns.
  • IRS sends one or more automated letters asking for the missing return or payment.
  • If no response, the IRS may prepare an SFR and issue an assessment.
  • After assessment, additional notices demand payment and offer collection options.
  • Continued nonresponse can lead to a Notice of Federal Tax Lien, levy on wages or bank accounts, and enforced collection actions.

The automated nature of the process makes early responses critical. A single timely filing (even without full payment) often halts escalation and opens the door to payment plans or other relief. (IRS — Collection Process and Fresh Start program guidance.)

Who is most likely to be flagged

Certain groups are more vulnerable to automated detection:

  • Freelancers, contractors, gig workers and anyone who receives 1099‑series forms.
  • Small business owners and sole proprietors with bank and merchant reports.
  • People who received unemployment, retirement distributions, or other taxable income reported by third parties.
  • Individuals with previously consistent filing who stop filing because of illness, divorce, or homelessness.

The IRS has improved data sources and cross‑agency matches, so having a mix of reportable income without a matching return is the primary trigger.

Real consequences: what can happen if you remain a non‑filer

  • Automated assessments that ignore deductions or credits you would claim.
  • Accumulated penalties and interest that increase the balance quickly.
  • Notice of Federal Tax Lien recorded against property, which harms credit and complicates lending. See our article on Tax Liens and Levies: What They Mean and How to Stop Them for more on the effects and options to respond. (FinHelp glossary)
  • Levy actions that seize wages, bank accounts, or other assets.
  • Difficulty qualifying for mortgages or business credit while a lien or levy is in place.

If a taxpayer is eligible for an Offer in Compromise or other resolution, that option becomes harder to pursue after an SFR or aggressive collection step. Learn about filing an Offer in Compromise and eligibility considerations in our guide Filing an Offer in Compromise: Eligibility, Process, and Tips. (FinHelp glossary)

Practical steps to stop automated collections (immediate checklist)

  1. Gather documents now: W‑2s, all 1099s, bank statements, prior returns, and Social Security statements. Good records let you file accurate returns and rebut SFRs.
  2. File the missing returns ASAP. Filing often halts the automated notice sequence and prevents or reverses an SFR. If you cannot pay in full, file anyway to reduce failure‑to‑file penalties.
  3. If an SFR was prepared, file the correct return and clearly explain differences. The IRS can adjust an SFR if you file a timely, accurate return for the year in question.
  4. Request a payment plan online or by phone. The IRS accepts installment agreements for many balances and has low‑income options. (IRS Online Payment Agreement.)
  5. Consider penalty relief. The IRS offers First‑Time Penalty Abatement and other relief in cases of reasonable cause — documented illness, natural disaster, or incorrect advice. Ask for abatement when you first contact the IRS.
  6. If collections are underway (liens, levies), seek professional help immediately — there are strict notice and response timelines.

When to seek professional help or free assistance

  • You have multiple years of unfiled returns.
  • An SFR has been assessed against you.
  • You face a lien, levy, or wage garnishment.
  • You suspect identity theft or IRS impersonation in the process.

Resources:

  • Tax professionals and enrolled agents can prepare past returns and negotiate with the IRS.
  • The Taxpayer Advocate Service (TAS) helps taxpayers when IRS processes create hardship or delay. (IRS — Taxpayer Advocate Service.)
  • Low Income Taxpayer Clinics (LITCs) provide free or low‑cost representation to qualifying taxpayers.

Common myths and mistakes

  • Myth: “If I can’t pay, I shouldn’t file.” Wrong. Filing reduces the failure‑to‑file penalty and preserves deductions and credits.
  • Myth: “The IRS won’t notice a small income.” Wrong — the IRS receives wide coverage from third‑party reporting and small‑amount reports are often enough to flag missing returns.
  • Mistake: Ignoring the first notice. Automated letters are designed to be simple triggers — ignoring them almost always leads to escalation.

How I handle non‑filer cases (professional insight)

In my practice, early organization and filing are the two most effective defenses. Clients who file before the IRS prepares an SFR usually avoid inflated assessments and qualify for installment agreements or penalty abatement. When an SFR exists, a properly prepared amended return or original return that documents deductions, credits, and substantiation often reduces assessed tax substantially. Speed and documentation are the keys.

Remedies the IRS commonly offers

  • Installment agreements (including short‑term extensions in some cases).
  • Penalty abatement for reasonable cause or first‑time abatement.
  • Offer in Compromise when collection of the full liability would create economic hardship — eligibility depends on a full financial disclosure. See our guide on Filing an Offer in Compromise: Eligibility, Process, and Tips. (FinHelp glossary)
  • Withdrawal or subordination of liens in narrow circumstances; often tied to payment plans or financing needs. See Tax Liens and Levies: What They Mean and How to Stop Them for options to challenge or remove liens. (FinHelp glossary)

Sources and further reading

  • IRS — Collection Process and your rights: see the IRS pages on collections, Fresh Start initiatives, and penalty relief (IRS.gov).
  • IRS — Third‑party information reporting: how the IRS matches Forms W‑2, 1099 series and other data to tax returns.
  • IRS — Taxpayer Advocate Service and Low Income Taxpayer Clinics (TAS/LITC) resources.
  • Consumer Financial Protection Bureau — guidance on tax debt and its effect on credit and collections.

Professional Disclaimer: This article is educational and does not replace individualized tax advice. If you have unfiled returns or active IRS collection actions, consult a qualified tax professional, an enrolled agent, or the Taxpayer Advocate Service for help tailored to your situation.

FinHelp internal resources:

Act promptly: filing missing returns and contacting the IRS or a tax professional early is the best way to stop automated collections from turning into long‑term financial problems.