How contribution limits are set and why they matter
The IRS sets contribution limits for retirement accounts each year to control how much tax-advantaged saving an individual can receive. Limits vary by account type (401(k), Traditional IRA, Roth IRA, SEP IRA, SIMPLE IRA) and by age (catch-up contributions for people age 50 and older). The limits are indexed periodically for inflation and can change from year to year — always confirm the current year limits on the IRS limits page (see: https://www.irs.gov/retirement-plans/plan-participant-employee/retirement-plan-contribution-limits).
Why this matters: contributions determine tax treatment (deductibility for traditional IRAs, tax-free growth for Roths, employer matches, and your eligibility for tax credits). Overcontributing can create immediate tax problems and recurring penalties until fixed.
Common account rules and examples (useful frame of reference)
- IRAs (Traditional and Roth): contribution limits apply to the combined total you place into all IRAs you own in a given tax year. For example, in 2023 the combined limit was $6,500 (plus a $1,000 catch-up if age 50+). Always check the IRS page for the current year.
- 401(k), 403(b), most 457 plans: elective deferral limits apply to how much you personally defer from paychecks; employer contributions are subject to separate limits that govern total annual additions. In 2023, the elective deferral limit was $22,500 (with a $7,500 catch-up for those 50+). Employer + employee limits are separate and subject to overall contribution caps.
These examples illustrate two important points: 1) IRA limits are aggregated across accounts (contributing to multiple IRA custodians doesn’t give you multiple full limits); 2) 401(k) employee deferrals and overall employer-added contributions are tracked differently.
(For deeper reading on IRAs, see our glossary entry: Individual Retirement Arrangement (IRA).)
What happens if you overcontribute?
Consequences depend on the account type and whether you correct the excess by the deadline:
-
IRA excess contributions: generally subject to a 6% excise tax for each year the excess remains in the account. To avoid the 6% penalty for the current year, you must withdraw the excess contribution (and any earnings attributable to it) by the tax-filing deadline (typically April 15, or the extended date if you file for an extension may not remove the 6% tax — timing rules matter). If you miss the deadline, the 6% continues to apply each year until the excess is removed or absorbed by using future contribution room.
-
IRS reference: see “Excess Contributions” guidance at https://www.irs.gov/retirement-plans/ira-excess-contributions and Publication 590-A.
-
401(k) excess deferrals: if you contribute more than the elective deferral limit through one or multiple employers, this is treated as an “excess deferral.” The usual correction is that the plan administrator should distribute the excess (and earnings) to you by April 15 following the year of the deferral. If distributed by that deadline, the excess is taxable in the year it went into the plan, and any earnings are taxable in the year distributed. If not corrected timely, you face the risk of double taxation (income included in two different years) and have fewer automatic correction options.
-
IRS reference: retirement topics on excess deferrals: https://www.irs.gov/retirement-plans/plan-participant-employee/retirement-topics-excess-deferrals
-
Employer contribution limits and nondiscrimination issues: employers must follow separate rules that can result in plan corrections (for example, returning excess employer contributions or performing corrective distributions) or reporting adjustments if a plan fails nondiscrimination testing.
Correcting an overcontribution — step-by-step practical guide
-
Confirm the excess. Gather 401(k) pay stubs, year-to-date contribution totals from payroll/plan portals, and IRA contribution records. Verify whether catch-up contributions (age 50+) were correctly applied.
-
Contact the plan administrator or IRA custodian as soon as possible. For 401(k) excess deferrals, the plan sponsor typically handles corrective distributions. For IRAs, request the removal of the excess contribution and any attributable earnings.
-
Remove excess and earnings by the tax-filing deadline when possible. For IRAs, withdrawing the excess and earnings by the tax return due date (usually April 15) generally avoids the 6% excise tax for that year. Any earnings on an excess IRA contribution are taxable in the year they are withdrawn and may be subject to early-distribution penalties if you’re under age 59½.
-
Report the correction properly on your tax return. You may need to: include the distributed earnings in income for the correct year; file Form 5329 to report excise taxes if you owe them; and correct W-2 reporting for 401(k) distributions if necessary.
-
If you miss the deadline: remove the excess as soon as you can and file Form 5329 to report and calculate the 6% excise tax for each taxable year the excess remained. If the excess is not removed, it will continue to accrue the 6% penalty each year until corrected or absorbed.
-
Keep written confirmation. Retain letters or account statements that show the corrective distribution and earnings calculation. You may need them if the IRS questions the handling.
IRS forms and publications commonly involved: Publication 590-A and 590-B (IRAs), instructions for Form 5329 (excise taxes), and plan-level guidance found on IRS retirement plan pages. Always consult the current IRS guidance for year-specific procedures.
Real-world scenarios and common mistakes (practical notes from my practice)
-
Multiple jobs: Clients with more than one employer occasionally overshoot elective deferral limits because each payroll system withholds without cross-checking. If you work two W-2 jobs and exceed the elective deferral limit, contact one or both plan admins immediately to request corrective action.
-
Multiple IRAs: People sometimes think separate custodians mean separate limits. I’ve helped clients who contributed to several IRAs thinking each contribution was allowed; the IRS views all Traditional IRAs combined for the annual limit.
-
Timing mistakes around Roth conversions and recharacterizations: Recharacterizations of conversions follow special rules — correct handling is critical to prevent accidental excess Roth contributions. See our guide on tax-diversification choices: Roth 401(k) vs Roth IRA: When to Use Each for Tax Diversification.
Practical tips to avoid overcontributing
- Track contributions in real time using a simple spreadsheet or the plan portals. Log every employer deferral and every IRA deposit.
- Coordinate with payroll if you change employers mid-year — ask HR to verify year-to-date elective deferrals before you set a new payroll deferral amount.
- Take advantage of catch-up contributions if eligible (age 50+). Confirm that catch-up contributions are being applied correctly by the plan.
- Use tools and alerts: many custodians and payroll systems can warn you when you approach limits.
- If unsure, pause contributions mid-year and consult a financial pro. It’s often easier to start contributions later than to unwind an excess.
When to get professional help
If an excess contribution is large, repeated, or involves complex plan interactions (multiple employers, conversions, spousal IRAs, or self-employment plans), work with a tax professional or financial advisor. In my 15 years of financial planning practice I’ve handled many corrections; advisors can liaise with plan administrators and prepare the correct tax forms to limit penalties.
For spousal contributions or special situations, see our related glossary: Spousal IRA Contribution Limits.
Authoritative sources and further reading
- IRS — Retirement Plan Contribution Limits: https://www.irs.gov/retirement-plans/plan-participant-employee/retirement-plan-contribution-limits
- IRS — Excess IRA Contributions: https://www.irs.gov/retirement-plans/ira-excess-contributions
- IRS — Retirement Topics: Excess Deferrals: https://www.irs.gov/retirement-plans/plan-participant-employee/retirement-topics-excess-deferrals
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau — retirement resources: https://www.consumerfinance.gov/consumer-tools/retirement/
Professional disclaimer
This article is educational and does not substitute for personalized tax or legal advice. Rules change, contribution limits are updated annually, and individual circumstances vary. Consult the IRS guidance linked above or a qualified tax advisor for help tailored to your situation.
If you want, I can add a downloadable checklist you can use to track contributions across employers and IRAs or a fillable worksheet to calculate excess amounts and required earnings adjustments.
