Quick overview
If you need money for home repairs, two common choices are a HELOC and an unsecured personal loan. HELOCs tap your home’s equity, act like a credit line, and are generally cheaper but put your home at risk. Personal loans are unsecured, predictable, and faster to close, but often carry higher interest and lower loan limits. The right choice depends on project size, timeline, interest-rate environment, and how much risk you’re willing to accept.
How each option works
HELOC — revolving, secured credit
- You borrow against the equity in your home; the lender places a lien on the property.
- You get a credit limit and can draw funds during a draw period (often 5–10 years).
- Most HELOCs have variable rates tied to an index (e.g., prime rate) so payments can change.
- After the draw period you enter repayment (sometimes with interest-only payments during draw) and must repay principal and interest.
Strengths: lower starting rates, flexible draws, useful for staged projects.
Risks: rate increases, foreclosure risk if you default, potential closing costs.
Personal loan — fixed, unsecured lump sum
- You receive the full loan amount at closing and repay fixed monthly payments over a set term (commonly 2–7 years).
- Most personal loans are unsecured, so there’s no lien on your home.
- Rates are typically fixed and depend on credit score, income, and debt-to-income ratio.
Strengths: predictable payments, faster closing, no home lien (usually).
Risks: higher rates than secured credit, smaller loan amounts, possible origination fees.
Cost comparison and real numbers (example)
These are illustrative calculations based on typical 2024–2025 market levels; shop rates for current pricing.
- HELOC example: $40,000 drawn at a 5.0% variable rate. If interest-only during a 10-year draw, monthly interest ≈ $167 (5% × $40,000 / 12). If rates rise, payments rise.
- Personal loan example: $40,000 at 10% fixed for 7 years. Monthly payment ≈ $706. Total interest over 7 years ≈ $19,000.
Which is cheaper depends on how long you carry debt and rate movement. A HELOC can be far cheaper short-term, but rising rates or a long payoff horizon can change that math.
Tax and legal considerations
- Interest deductibility: Under current IRS rules (as of 2025) interest on a HELOC is deductible only when the loan proceeds are used to buy, build, or substantially improve the home that secures the loan. See IRS Publication 936 for details and limits on secured-home interest deductions (IRS.gov).
- Personal loan interest is generally not tax deductible for home repairs (unless you itemize and meet special rules; consult a tax advisor).
- Legal risk: a HELOC uses your home as collateral. If you default, the lender can foreclose. Personal loans generally don’t put your home directly at risk but default still damages credit and can lead to collection actions.
Sources: IRS Publication 936 (Home Mortgage Interest Deduction), Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) guidance on HELOCs and personal loans (consumerfinance.gov).
Who typically benefits from each option
-
Choose a HELOC if:
-
You have substantial home equity and a solid payment plan.
-
Projects are large or staged (e.g., whole-house remodeling) and you prefer to draw incrementally.
-
You can tolerate variable rates or plan to convert to a fixed-rate loan later.
-
Choose a personal loan if:
-
You prefer predictable payments and a known payoff date.
-
You don’t have sufficient equity or don’t want a lien on your home.
-
Repairs are smaller or you want a fast, simple closing.
In my practice, homeowners who need funds for multi-phase renovations (kitchen, then roofing, then HVAC) often prefer a HELOC for flexibility. Those who want to avoid market-rate variability and close quickly tend to choose a personal loan.
Eligibility, underwriting, and credit impact
- HELOC lenders evaluate loan-to-value (LTV), credit score, income, and loan history; typical maximum combined LTVs range between 80% and 90% depending on lender.
- Personal loans are priced heavily on credit score and debt-to-income. Borrowers with excellent credit can secure competitive fixed rates; borrowers with thin credit may need a cosigner or a secured personal loan.
- Both product types involve a hard credit inquiry that can temporarily lower your credit score. Responsible repayment improves credit over time.
When to refinance or convert
- If you start with a HELOC and rates spike or you want fixed payments, consider refinancing into a fixed-rate home equity loan or a personal installment loan. Many lenders offer HELOC conversion options—compare closing costs and the APR.
- If you take a personal loan and later build equity, a HELOC or cash-out refinance could become attractive for larger projects.
For related guidance on safe HELOC use for renovations, see Using HELOCs Safely for Home Improvements (FinHelp). For tax-specific questions about using loans for renovations, see Using Personal Loans for Home Renovation: Pros, Cons and Tax Aspects (FinHelp).
- HELOC safety guide: https://finhelp.io/glossary/using-helocs-safely-for-home-improvements/
- Personal loan tax guide: https://finhelp.io/glossary/using-personal-loans-for-home-renovation-pros-cons-and-tax-aspects/
Step-by-step decision checklist
- Define the project scope and budget: single repair under $10k vs. multi-stage $50k+ remodel.
- Get contractor estimates with timelines to determine whether you need staged draws or a lump sum.
- Check current interest rates and compare APRs (include fees and closing costs).
- Calculate monthly payments for both options at realistic rates and worst-case rate scenarios for a HELOC.
- Evaluate tax impact: will HELOC interest be deductible under IRS rules? (See IRS Publication 936.)
- Consider risk tolerance: does your household budget absorb rising HELOC payments if rates increase?
- Choose the product that matches project timing, cost, and risk tolerance — then shop lenders for the best APR and terms.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Borrowing the full available HELOC limit “just because you can.” Take only what you need.
- Ignoring conversion or balloon clauses—some HELOCs force full amortization after the draw period.
- Overlooking fees: origination fees on personal loans and appraisal/closing fees on HELOCs affect total cost.
- Assuming interest is tax-deductible without confirming use of funds and IRS rules.
Example decision scenarios
- Small emergency repair ($2,000–$10,000): personal loan or credit card with 0% intro could be best for speed.
- Medium repair ($10,000–$35,000), predictable timeline: compare personal loan vs. HELOC balance — if you can pay down within 3–5 years, a HELOC may be cheaper.
- Large renovation ($40,000+), multi-stage: HELOC usually wins for flexibility, but plan for rate variability or lock a portion into a fixed-rate.
FAQs (short answers)
- Can I use a HELOC for any home repair and still deduct interest? Not always. Under IRS rules, deductibility hinges on using proceeds to buy, build, or substantially improve the home securing the loan. See IRS Publication 936.
- Can I get a HELOC with bad credit? Unlikely. HELOCs require equity and underwriting; lenders favor higher credit scores and low DTI.
- Which affects my home equity faster? Making only interest payments on a HELOC delays equity paydown; principal payments reduce equity more quickly.
Final recommendations
- For predictable budgeting and smaller projects, a personal loan is often the simplest, lowest-risk choice.
- For large, staged, or long-term renovations where lower initial cost and draw flexibility matter, a HELOC can be the better tool — if you have adequate equity and a plan to manage rate risk.
Professional disclaimer: This article is educational and not personalized financial or tax advice. Your situation may differ. Consult a CPA or licensed financial advisor and review IRS Publication 936 and Consumer Financial Protection Bureau materials before choosing a loan product.
Author note: As a CPA and financial advisor, I advise clients to model both worst-case HELOC rate increases and realistic repayment timelines before borrowing. When possible, get multiple lender quotes and request each offer’s APR and fees in writing.
Authoritative sources and further reading
- IRS Publication 936 — Home Mortgage Interest Deduction (IRS.gov)
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau — Compare loans and HELOC guidance (consumerfinance.gov)
- FinHelp: Using HELOCs Safely for Home Improvements — https://finhelp.io/glossary/using-helocs-safely-for-home-improvements/
- FinHelp: Using Personal Loans for Home Renovation: Pros, Cons and Tax Aspects — https://finhelp.io/glossary/using-personal-loans-for-home-renovation-pros-cons-and-tax-aspects/
