How these documents work and why they matter

Healthcare proxies (also called a healthcare power of attorney or agent) and living wills are complementary legal instruments used when a person can’t communicate medical preferences. The proxy names who will decide; the living will describes what should be decided. When both exist, clinicians and hospital ethics teams use the living will to guide the proxy’s choices and resolve disputes.

In my 15 years advising families on elder care and incapacity planning, I’ve seen clear, well-drafted documents prevent hours of agonizing debate and reduce delays in care. Conversely, vague or missing language often forces courts and clinicians into default rules that may not reflect the patient’s wishes.

(American Bar Association guidance outlines common state differences and drafting considerations — see americanbar.org.)

Basic drafting checklist (step-by-step)

  1. Pick an agent you trust and confirm willingness.
  • Choose someone who understands your values and can communicate under stress.
  • Name alternates in order — people decline or become unavailable.
  1. Define the agent’s authority and limits.
  • Specify whether the agent can accept or refuse life-sustaining treatment, consent to hospice care, or make organ donation decisions.
  • Use precise language (see sample phrases below) to reduce interpretation gaps.
  1. Describe treatment preferences in a living will.
  • Address resuscitation (CPR), mechanical ventilation, artificial nutrition/hydration, antibiotics, and pain management.
  • You can include general values (e.g., quality of life preferences) and specific directives for common scenarios.
  1. State activation criteria.
  • Define when the proxy’s authority begins (e.g., when two physicians or one physician and a psychologist determine you lack capacity).
  • Some states use medical determinations, others allow your own declaration; check state law.
  1. Follow state execution rules.
  • Many states require one or two witnesses; some require notarization. Confirm your state’s formalities.
  1. Share and store copies.
  • Give copies to the agent, alternates, primary care physician, and hospital records. Keep a notarized original accessible.
  1. Review periodically and after major life changes.
  • Update after marriage, divorce, diagnosis, relocation, or change in values.

Practical drafting language (examples and tips)

Use clear, direct language. Below are neutral examples—work with an attorney to tailor to your state:

  • Agent appointment: “I appoint [Name] as my health care agent to make health care decisions for me when I lack the capacity to make those decisions myself.”

  • Limiting authority: “My agent may not withhold antibiotics for treatable infections unless they would only prolong the dying process.”

  • Life-sustaining treatment: “If I have an irreversible condition and am unable to communicate, I refuse mechanical ventilation and artificial nutrition intended to prolong life.”

  • Values statement: “I value independence and cognitive awareness over mere biological survival; avoid aggressive, burdensome treatments that only extend the dying process.”

Concrete phrases reduce ambiguity. Avoid broad wording like “do everything possible,” which is open to interpretation.

Witnesses, notarization, and state differences

Execution formalities vary. Typical rules:

  • Witnesses: Most states require one or two witnesses who are not your named agent or direct heirs.
  • Notarization: Some states add a notarization requirement to strengthen portability across providers.
  • POLST/MOLST: Separate physician-ordered forms (POLST, called MOLST in some states) translate your wishes into medical orders. Living wills and proxies do not replace POLST when immediate orders are needed.

Always check current state requirements or consult an attorney. The U.S. Department of Health & Human Services provides general resources on advance directives (hhs.gov).

Coordination with other documents

Coordinate your healthcare proxy and living will with:

Common drafting mistakes and how to avoid them

  • Failing to name alternates. Solution: Name at least two alternates and state the order.
  • Using vague value statements without specifics. Solution: Pair a values statement with concrete treatment preferences.
  • Forgetting to sign or notarize per state law. Solution: Confirm formalities and record the execution date and witnesses.
  • Not communicating with the chosen agent. Solution: Have candid conversations and provide written notes on your priorities.

In my practice, the most common error is assuming family members will “just know” what you’d want. Even close relatives often disagree on what constitutes acceptable quality of life.

Special situations

  • Advance dementia planning: Specify preferences for dementia-stage care (feeding, hospitalization thresholds, and transfer to inpatient care).
  • Religious or cultural considerations: State religious accommodations (e.g., blood transfusion refusals) clearly.
  • Minor children: A healthcare proxy for a parent doesn’t usually name a guardian for minor children; use a parenting plan or guardian designation in a will.

How clinicians and hospitals use these documents

Hospitals and clinicians use the living will to interpret the patient’s values and the proxy to make decisions consistent with those values. If a proxy’s decision conflicts with facility policy, hospitals typically consult ethics committees or seek legal guidance. Clear, specific language reduces such conflicts and the likelihood of court involvement.

Practical storage and digital tools

  • Keep an original signed document in a safe, accessible place. Provide certified copies to your agent and primary care clinician.
  • Use a secure digital repository that allows quick access in emergencies. Document metadata should include the execution date and state of execution.

Frequently asked legal questions (brief)

  • Can I revoke or change these documents? Yes — you can revoke or amend while competent. Notify all parties and replace prior copies.
  • Do hospitals have to follow them? Generally yes if valid and applicable; exceptions exist for emergency care or compliance conflicts. Hospitals follow state law and internal policies.
  • Do I need a lawyer? Not always, but a lawyer ensures compliance with state rules and helps tailor complex instructions.

Red flags to discuss with an attorney

  • Cross-state moves or property/medical care across multiple states.
  • Conflicting documents (e.g., older documents that name different agents).
  • Complex medical preferences (e.g., specific therapies or experimental treatments).

Final tips and action plan

  1. Print and sign your proxy and living will following your state’s rules.
  2. Talk with your chosen agent and at least one alternate.
  3. Give copies to your agent, clinician, and family members who need to know.
  4. Revisit every 3–5 years or after major life events.

This article is educational and not legal advice. For state-specific drafting and formal execution, consult an attorney licensed in your state or an elder-care specialist. See resources from the U.S. Department of Health & Human Services and the American Bar Association for additional guidance (https://www.hhs.gov/; https://www.americanbar.org/).

Author note: Over the last decade and a half, I’ve helped dozens of families convert vague wishes into clear, usable directives. That clarity matters — it spares loved ones unnecessary conflict and helps medical teams deliver care consistent with your values.

— End of article