Why this matters

Payroll withholding is a recurring trust obligation: employers collect employees’ federal income tax and federal employment taxes and must deposit and report them accurately and on time. Mistakes can produce underpayments, employee tax surprises at year‑end, and employer penalties (including trust‑fund related penalties). See IRS Publication 15 (Employer’s Tax Guide) for employer responsibilities. (IRS.gov)

How withholding is supposed to work — brief overview

  • Employees complete and submit Form W‑4; employers use that form and IRS methods (Publication 15‑T) or payroll software tax tables to calculate federal income tax to withhold. (IRS Pub. 15‑T)
  • Employers deposit withheld federal income tax and the employee/employer share of FICA according to IRS deposit schedules, and report payroll taxes on Form 941 (or Form 944 if eligible).

Common mistakes employers make (and why they happen)

1) Using outdated or missing W‑4 information

  • Problem: Relying on an old W‑4 or not obtaining a completed W‑4 for new hires can lead to wrong withholding amounts.
  • Fix: Require a current signed W‑4 on hire and prompt updates for life‑changing events; when no W‑4 is provided use IRS default withholding rules. See IRS guidance on Form W‑4.

2) Misapplying withholding methods for supplemental wages (bonuses, commissions)

  • Problem: Treating supplemental wages the same as regular wages can under- or over‑withhold.
  • Fix: Follow IRS rules for supplemental wages (use the aggregate or flat‑rate method as appropriate) and configure payroll software accordingly. (IRS Pub. 15)

3) Using stale tax tables or incorrect software settings

  • Problem: Annual tax table updates, changes to payroll frequency, or wrong filing status settings can produce repeated errors.
  • Fix: Update payroll software and tax tables each year, and verify settings after software upgrades or organizational changes.

4) Failing to deposit withheld taxes or filing late returns

  • Problem: Missing deposits or late Form 941 filings creates penalties and interest, and can trigger enforcement actions.
  • Fix: Reconcile payroll monthly, follow IRS deposit schedules, and make timely corrections using Form 941‑X if prior deposits or reported amounts were wrong. (Form 941 & 941‑X instructions, IRS.gov)

5) Mishandling overwithholding or underwithholding corrections for employees

  • Problem: Employers are sometimes unsure whether to refund overwithheld amounts directly or let employees claim credit on their return; underwithholding leaves employees with larger tax bills.
  • Fix: For overwithholding, you can refund via payroll (best practice to treat as a payroll correction) or advise employees how to claim a refund on their individual return. For substantial underwithholding, adjust future payroll withholding immediately and consider issuing corrected W‑4 guidance; employees may still owe tax and should be advised to consult a tax professional.

6) Ignoring backup withholding, nonresident alien rules, and third‑party payments

  • Problem: Not recognizing when backup withholding or special rules for nonresident aliens apply.
  • Fix: Follow IRS backup withholding rules (Form 945) and withholding rules for nonresident aliens; consider specialist help for cross‑border payroll. See our guide on backup withholding.

How to correct discovered withholding errors — step‑by‑step

  1. Stop and document
  • Identify the error, affected pay periods and employees, and the amounts under‑ or over‑withheld.
  1. Communicate with affected employees
  • Notify impacted employees promptly, explain next steps, and describe whether they’ll receive a payroll correction or need to claim a refund on their return. Keep the communication factual and documented.
  1. Fix employer returns and deposits
  • Use Form 941‑X to correct previously filed Form 941 for the quarter(s) with errors. For deposits that were missed or short, deposit the amount with interest and penalties or work with the IRS to arrange a payment. (IRS Form 941‑X guidance)
  1. Correct payroll records and withhold going forward
  • Process payroll adjustments (refunds or additional withholding) in a timely pay period; if refunds are processed, ensure payroll taxes (FICA, FUTA) are handled correctly. Reissue corrected W‑2s if needed.
  1. Seek professional help when liability or willfulness is a concern
  • If withholding failures are large, persistent, or potentially willful, consult a payroll tax attorney or CPA. The IRS may assess the Trust Fund Recovery Penalty for willful failure to collect and pay withheld income and employment taxes.

In my practice, I’ve seen first‑time employers assume contractor withholding rules apply to employees — that error required filing Form 941‑X and reclassifying payroll retroactively. Correcting early, documenting steps, and training staff prevented repeat issues.

Preventive best practices (quick checklist)

  • Collect and retain a current Form W‑4 for every employee and prompt updates after major life changes.
  • Run quarterly payroll reconciliations to catch errors before they roll into annual reporting.
  • Update payroll software tax tables annually and after system changes.
  • Use the IRS Withholding Estimator and Publication 15/15‑T as primary authoritative references.
  • Consider outsourced payroll or a CPA for complex payroll (multistate, nonresident aliens, supplemental pay).

Where to learn more / resources

  • IRS Publication 15 (Employer’s Tax Guide) and Publication 15‑T (federal income tax withholding methods) — IRS.gov
  • Form 941 and Form 941‑X instructions (to correct previously filed returns) — IRS.gov
  • IRS Withholding Estimator (for employee withholding scenarios) — IRS.gov
  • Department of Labor: payroll and tax responsibilities — DOL.gov

Related FinHelp articles

Professional disclaimer

This article is educational only and does not substitute for personalized tax or legal advice. For specific corrections or potential penalties, consult a qualified CPA, tax attorney, or the IRS directly.

Author note

As a payroll and tax consultant working with small businesses, I’ve helped clients correct withholding errors using Form 941‑X, update W‑4 practices, and implement quarterly payroll audits to prevent recurrence.