Overview
Establishing state income tax residency decides which state(s) can tax your income, and it matters for wages, investment returns, retirement income, and sale-of-home events. States use different legal tests — and many combine multiple tests — so two people with similar facts can end up in different tax positions depending on the states involved. In my 15+ years advising clients on moves and residency disputes, small documentation gaps or mixed signals (like keeping a home in the former state while applying for a new driver’s license) are the most common triggers of state audits and unexpected tax bills.
Sources: state tax departments, the Multistate Tax Commission, and the Tax Foundation provide guidance on state rules. See, for example, the Multistate Tax Commission’s overview on residency and domicile and general federal distinctions on residency at the IRS site (note: the IRS governs federal, not state, residency tests) (Multistate Tax Commission, IRS).
Key factors states use to decide residency
States look at the whole person — a mix of objective facts and subjective intent. The most common factors are:
-
Physical presence (days in the state): Many states apply a days-based or “statutory” test (often using a 183-day threshold). If you exceed the state’s days test you may be treated as a resident for that year. Several states apply a strict day-count; others combine days with additional requirements.
-
Domicile (permanent home and intent): Domicile is your true, fixed, permanent home — where you intend to return after absences. Courts and revenue agencies weigh your stated intent together with documentary evidence (lease or deed, location of personal belongings, where you spend holidays, etc.).
-
Financial and social ties: Bank accounts, the location of your primary physician, professional licenses, business registrations, and where you receive mail are persuasive indicators.
-
Government records: Driver’s license, vehicle registration, passport address, voter registration, and where you file state tax returns all influence determinations.
-
Family, education, and community connections: Where your spouse and children live, where kids attend school, and where you hold professional or religious memberships matters.
-
Employment and business activity: The source of pay and where the employer is located can drive withholding and nonresident tax liabilities.
Common residency tests used by states
-
Domicile test — asks where your permanent home is. Changing domicile requires proof of intent and actions that demonstrate settling into a new state.
-
Statutory or days test — counts days present in the state; surpassing the threshold typically creates residency for tax purposes.
-
Combination tests — some states apply both (e.g., you can be domiciled in one state but treated as a resident of another under a statutory test).
-
Part-year and split-year rules — when you change residency during the year, most states prorate tax liability or require part-year resident returns.
Be aware: states like New York, Connecticut, and others have well-known statutory residency rules (New York’s rules combine “domicile” and a 183-day presence test plus a permanent place of abode requirement). Always check the specific state tax authority for current rules.
Authoritative starting points: Multistate Tax Commission, state department of revenue pages, and Tax Foundation state guides.
Risks and consequences of getting it wrong
-
Audits and residency investigations: When facts are mixed or your ties look split, states may audit to reclassify you as a resident and assess additional tax.
-
Back taxes, interest, and penalties: If a state reasserts residency for prior years you can owe unpaid tax plus interest and penalties. Interest rates and penalty structures vary by state.
-
Double taxation: If two states both claim residency, you can face overlapping tax bills. Some states offer credits for taxes paid to another state, but those credits have limits and rules.
-
Withholding and cash-flow shocks: Employers may withhold at the state rate of your reported address; correcting withholding retroactively can be painful.
-
Non-tax consequences: Residency determinations can affect estate tax exposure, in-state tuition eligibility, and eligibility for state benefits.
Practical steps to establish — and document — a new residency
If you move and want to establish clear residency in the new state, take these steps and document each action:
- Change your primary address on federal and state tax returns and with the IRS where applicable; file the correct state return type (resident, nonresident, or part-year resident).
- Obtain a driver’s license and vehicle registration in the new state as soon as allowed.
- Register to vote and vote in the new state.
- Transfer medical care (primary physician) and move memberships (gyms, religious organizations) to the new state.
- Rent or buy a permanent place in the new state and document lease or purchase contracts, moving receipts, and utility bills.
- Update financial accounts and ensure statements show the new address; consider consolidating banking in the new state if appropriate.
- Sever ties with the old state: sell or rent out the old home, cancel local subscriptions, update estate documents and wills to reflect new domicile.
- Keep a contemporaneous day log showing where you slept each night (many clients use a simple dated calendar or a digital travel log) and retain travel tickets, hotel receipts, and meetings.
In my practice, clients who maintain a contemporaneous day log plus a folder of address-change documents withstand audits far better than those trying to reconstruct facts years later.
Special situations
-
Remote and hybrid workers: Your work location, employer withholding, and where you perform services can create nexus for taxation. Several states have enacted source-based rules for remote-work income. See our guide on Remote Work and State Residency: Avoiding Multistate Tax Surprises.
-
Snowbirds and seasonal migrants: States have special rules about part-year residents and statutory residency for seasonal visitors. For planning tips, see our article on State Residency Planning for Seasonal Migrants (Snowbirds).
-
High-net-worth individuals and business owners: Complex holdings, corporate addresses, and multiple residences raise scrutiny. Multistate arrangements should be driven by documented intent and carefully structured evidence.
-
Students: College students often retain domicile in the parents’ state; specific rules depend on whether the student intends to return.
How disputes are resolved
If a state disagrees with your residency claim you may receive a notice proposing additional tax. Typical resolution paths include:
- Providing documentary evidence to the state auditor (utility bills, DMV registrations, voter records, affidavits).
- Negotiating settlements or filing an administrative appeal with the department of revenue.
- Filing a refund claim or petition in state tax court if an assessment is issued and you believe it’s incorrect.
- Using voluntary disclosure programs (for business or unfiled returns) in some states to mitigate penalties.
Always consult a tax attorney or CPA experienced in residency disputes — the procedural rules, appeal deadlines, and documentation requirements differ by state.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Relying on memory rather than contemporaneous records for day counts.
- Leaving conflicting records (a driver’s license in the new state but voter registration in the old state).
- Assuming intent alone is enough; many states require supporting actions that reflect that intent.
- Forgetting that nonresident source income (like wages earned in another state) may still be taxable where the income is earned.
Example scenarios (anonymized)
-
Case A: A client moved from California to Texas, obtained a Texas driver’s license, sold the California home, and changed bank accounts. Because they documented steps taken and maintained few ties to California, we successfully established Texas domicile and avoided California residency assessments for subsequent years.
-
Case B: A client who split time between New York and Florida kept a NYC apartment, returned for many weekends, retained a New York driver’s license, and had significant New York business ties. New York challenged their Florida residency claim; lacking a convincing break with New York, the client settled the audit with back taxes.
These examples illustrate that proofs of intent must be backed by actions.
Practical checklist when you change states
- File part-year or resident tax returns as required.
- Update driver’s license, vehicle registration, and voter registration.
- Move primary bank accounts and update beneficiary, estate, and insurance documents.
- Keep a day-by-day presence log for at least three years after a move.
- Keep a relocation file with leases, closing statements, bills, and employment records.
Resources and authoritative references
- Multistate Tax Commission, “Residence and Domicile” guidance: https://www.mtc.gov
- Tax Foundation, state tax guides: https://taxfoundation.org
- IRS (federal residency distinctions, not state): https://www.irs.gov
- For state-specific rules, consult the state department of revenue or taxation website for the states involved (e.g., New York Dept. of Taxation and Finance, California Franchise Tax Board).
Internal reading from FinHelp:
- State Residency Planning: Steps to Legitimize a Tax Move — https://finhelp.io/glossary/state-residency-planning-steps-to-legitimize-a-tax-move/
- State Residency Rules: When You Owe Taxes to Multiple States — https://finhelp.io/glossary/state-residency-rules-when-you-owe-taxes-to-multiple-states/
- Remote Work and State Residency: Avoiding Multistate Tax Surprises — https://finhelp.io/glossary/remote-work-and-state-residency-avoiding-multistate-tax-surprises/
Final notes and professional disclaimer
This article explains general principles for establishing state income tax residency and common risks as of 2025. It is educational in nature and does not substitute for personalized tax advice. State laws change, and nuanced facts can materially alter outcomes; consult a licensed tax professional or state tax counsel to analyze your situation.
(Authority: Multistate Tax Commission; Tax Foundation; state tax departments; IRS material on federal residency distinctions.)
