Quick summary
Converting a Traditional IRA to a Roth IRA means paying income tax on the converted amount in the year of conversion so future qualified withdrawals are tax-free. The conversion decision is fundamentally about timing your tax bill: pay tax now (Roth) or defer tax until withdrawal (Traditional). This guide explains the key criteria, common pitfalls, and practical steps — with examples and links to deeper resources — so you can build a conversion plan that fits your tax profile and retirement goals.
(Author note: I’m a financial professional with 15 years advising clients on retirement-tax strategies; this article is educational, not individualized tax advice.)
Why this decision matters
- Tax timing changes lifetime taxes and retirement cash flow. Paying tax now can reduce taxes later, lower required minimum distributions (RMD) pressure, and improve estate planning.
- A poor conversion can create an unexpected high tax bill, raise Medicare premiums (IRMAA), or increase Social Security taxation.
Authoritative starting points: see IRS guidance on Roth IRAs and Traditional IRAs for rules and tax consequences (IRS) Roth IRAs and Traditional IRAs.
Step-by-step decision checklist
- Quantify the taxable portion
- Determine how much of the account is pre-tax vs. after-tax. If you have nondeductible contributions, Form 8606 will show your basis and the taxable portion of a conversion; you must file Form 8606 when you convert. If you hold only pre-tax dollars, the entire conversion is taxable.
- Estimate current vs future marginal tax rates
- If you expect to be in a higher marginal tax bracket in retirement, a Roth conversion can save taxes long-term. If you expect a lower bracket, keeping money in a Traditional IRA may be better. Remember to factor federal and state income taxes. Also consider the effect of conversions on other thresholds (e.g., causing capital gains to be taxed more or triggering NIIT).
- Model multi-year conversions
-
Stagger conversions across several years to avoid pushing yourself into a higher tax bracket in any one year. Use years with unusually low income (e.g., job loss, business losses, or pre-retirement transition) to complete conversions at lower tax cost.
-
See finhelp’s guide on Roth Conversion Strategies for Low-Income Years for specific techniques.
- Account for the five-year rules and access to funds
- Each Roth conversion starts a five-tax-year clock for the converted amount to avoid the 10% early-withdrawal penalty if you are under age 59½ when you withdraw the converted principal. Qualified tax-free withdrawal of earnings requires both age 59½ (or another qualifying event) and a Roth IRA that’s been open five years.
- Think beyond income taxes
-
RMDs: Traditional IRAs require RMDs (age rule changed under SECURE 2.0; the RMD age is 73 for many taxpayers as of 2025). Roth IRAs do not have RMDs during the original owner’s lifetime, which helps reduce taxable income in retirement and can simplify estate planning.
-
Medicare IRMAA and premiums: A large conversion can raise your modified adjusted gross income (MAGI) for Medicare and trigger higher Part B/D premiums or IRMAA surcharges. For guidance on timing around Medicare, see finhelp’s article on Roth Conversions and Medicare: Timing to Avoid IRMAA Surprises.
-
Social Security taxation and NIIT: Increased MAGI may cause a greater portion of Social Security benefits to be taxed and may expose you to the Net Investment Income Tax.
- Use non-IRA funds to pay conversion taxes when possible
- Paying conversion taxes from outside the IRA preserves more retirement capital inside the Roth and maximizes the tax-free growth. Using IRA funds to pay conversion taxes reduces the conversion benefit and could trigger early withdrawal penalties if you are under 59½.
- Watch the pro-rata rule
- If you have both pre-tax and after-tax balances across IRAs, the taxable portion of any conversion is calculated pro-rata across all IRAs you own. You can’t cherry-pick only pre-tax money to convert unless you roll pre-tax IRA funds into an employer plan (if allowed) first.
- Document basis and file correctly
- Track your basis and file Form 8606 for nondeductible contributions and conversions. Missing or incorrect filings can lead to double taxation or headaches later.
- Remember the recharacterization rule is off the table
- You cannot recharacterize (undo) a Roth conversion back to a Traditional IRA. Congress eliminated recharacterizations of conversions in 2017 (effective 2018), so a conversion is a largely irreversible decision for tax years after 2017. That makes planning and tax projection more important.
- Employer plans and rollovers
- You can roll a pre-tax 401(k) to a Traditional IRA, then convert to Roth, or—if your plan allows—roll a 401(k) directly to a Roth 401(k) (which has its own rules). Check plan rules and tax consequences.
Short case studies (practical numbers)
A. The lower-income conversion window
- Sarah, age 55, expects a promotion in two years. She is in the 12% marginal bracket this year and projects 24% later. Converting $50,000 now would cost roughly $6,000 in federal tax (simplified for illustration), avoiding taxation at a higher rate later. She pays tax from cash savings to keep the entire $50,000 growing tax-free in the Roth.
B. Stagger to manage brackets
- Tom, age 50, has $200,000 in a Traditional IRA and $40,000 in reduced taxable income years. He converts $40,000 per year for five years, staying within lower bracket thresholds and smoothing the tax impact.
C. The Medicare/IRMAA trap
- Maria converts $150,000 in a single tax year. Her MAGI spikes, triggering an IRMAA surcharge and an unexpectedly higher Medicare premium for two years. Spreading conversions and timing relative to Medicare enrollment would have avoided that.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Converting the entire balance in one year without modeling tax consequences.
- Using conversion taxes paid from the IRA balance rather than outside funds when under age 59½.
- Overlooking state income taxes; some states tax conversions differently or have special rules.
- Forgetting Form 8606 and proof of after-tax basis — this can cause double taxation on the same dollars later.
- Assuming you can undo a conversion — recharacterization is no longer allowed for conversions.
Practical worksheet (what to run through before converting)
- Current and expected future federal and state marginal tax rates.
- MAGI calculations for the conversion year and effects on Medicare, Social Security, and NIIT.
- Source of funds to pay conversion tax (non-IRA funds preferred).
- Time horizon for investment growth in the Roth (longer horizons favor Roth conversions).
- Presence of after-tax basis in IRAs and application of the pro-rata rule.
- Whether you need liquidity from these funds in the next 5 years (consider five-year rule).
Where to learn more (authoritative resources)
- IRS — Roth IRAs: https://www.irs.gov/retirement-plans/plan-participant-employee/roth-iras
- IRS — Traditional IRAs: https://www.irs.gov/retirement-plans/plan-participant-employee/traditional-iras
- IRS — Form 8606 instructions (report nondeductible contributions and conversions): https://www.irs.gov/forms-pubs/about-form-8606
FinHelp interlinks for deeper strategies and timing
- For timing and tax strategies when converting, see our article on Converting a Traditional IRA to Roth: Timing and Tax Strategies.
- If you expect a low-income year, read Roth Conversion Strategies for Low-Income Years.
- For Medicare timing issues tied to conversions, consult Roth Conversions and Medicare: Timing to Avoid IRMAA Surprises.
Final recommendations
- Run a multi-year tax projection before converting large balances. Use tax software or work with a CPA/planner to model federal and state taxes, IRMAA, and Social Security interactions.
- Favor paying conversion taxes from outside the IRA to maximize compounding in the Roth.
- Stagger conversions and use low-income years when feasible.
- Keep precise records and file Form 8606 as required.
This guide is educational only and does not replace personalized tax or legal advice. For a conversion plan tailored to your situation — especially if you face complex issues (large balances, state tax differences, or Medicare eligibility) — consult a qualified tax professional or financial planner.
(Author: Experienced retirement tax advisor; facts checked against IRS guidance as of 2025.)
