Quick summary
E-filing is the dominant method for submitting U.S. individual tax returns: it’s faster, often cheaper, and includes built-in error checks and encryption. Paper filing still has a role—some taxpayers prefer it, and a few rare situations require it—but it typically results in slower refunds and greater risk of mail-related problems. The IRS recommends e-filing for most filers and continues to expand electronic options year to year (IRS.gov).
How e-filing and paper filing actually work
-
E-filing: You prepare your tax return using commercial tax software, a tax pro’s software, or IRS-authorized online services and transmit the return electronically to the IRS. The software validates entries (Social Security numbers, math, required schedules) before transmission; the IRS sends an acceptance or rejection notice within 24–48 hours. When accepted, most e-filed returns with direct deposit receive refunds within about 21 days, barring holds (IRS: Where’s My Refund?).
-
Paper filing: You complete physical tax forms, attach required schedules and documentation, sign them, and mail them to the IRS address for your state. The IRS must manually process mailed returns. Processing times for paper returns are much longer—commonly 6–8 weeks or more for refunds—and you don’t get a digital acceptance receipt.
Speed and timing — who wins?
- Advantage: E-filing. The IRS reports most e-filed returns with direct deposit are processed and refunds issued within about 21 days, compared with 6+ weeks for paper returns. If timing matters (refunds, meeting deadlines), e-file reduces time in the system. See IRS filing guidance for current timelines (IRS Filing Options).
In practice: In my client work I’ve seen e-file refunds arrive in as little as 7–14 days when there are no identity or credit issues; paper returns often took six weeks or longer.
Accuracy and error handling
- Advantage: E-filing. Tax software flags common mistakes (missing fields, inconsistent math, mismatches with W-2/1099 entries) which reduces IRS correspondence. Paper returns rely on manual checks and are more prone to arithmetic or omission errors.
But: E-file rejections happen—most often for mismatched names/SSNs, wrong prior-year AGI or PIN, or duplicate filings. If your e-file is rejected, follow the IRS guidance or see our article: “What to Do When the IRS Rejects Your E-File” (finhelp.io/glossary/what-to-do-when-the-irs-rejects-your-e-file/).
Security and privacy
-
E-filing advantages: Modern e-file systems use encryption, secure transmission protocols, and identity verification to reduce interception risk. The IRS and major vendors deploy security controls and monitoring. See the IRS e-file resources for technical details (IRS e-file options).
-
Paper disadvantages: Mail can be lost or delayed; sensitive documents in the mail are more vulnerable to theft. If you must mail, use secure envelopes and trackable postage.
Risk note: No system is perfect. Identity-theft-related refund holds and fraud attempts are growing concerns; if you suspect identity theft, follow IRS steps and our coverage on recovering a compromised tax account.
Cost and accessibility
-
E-filing: Many taxpayers can e-file free through IRS Free File (income limits apply) or through free tiers offered by software vendors. Paid software typically ranges from modest fees for basic returns to higher fees for complex returns. If you use a paid tax pro they often e-file as part of their service.
-
Paper filing: Direct costs are low—printing and postage—yet indirect costs can be higher: time spent printing, hand-signing, and mailing; delayed refunds create opportunity costs.
Accessibility: Paper filing still matters for people without reliable internet access or who prefer in-person help. Public libraries, community tax clinics, and Volunteer Income Tax Assistance (VITA) programs can assist filers with e-file at no cost.
Exceptions and special situations where paper may be needed
Paper filing is rare but still required or preferred in some situations:
- Certain attachments: If your return includes documents that can’t be submitted electronically (rare), paper may be necessary. Check IRS instructions or ask a tax pro.
- Complex trust or estate filings or nonresident returns sometimes have special filing pathways.
- Filers who prefer mailing signed originals for documentation or who are uncomfortable transmitting data online.
Note: The IRS has steadily expanded electronic filing options—see our explainer “Can You E-file Form 1040X?” for updates on amended returns and which forms can now be submitted electronically (finhelp.io/glossary/can-you-e-file-form-1040x/).
Recordkeeping and receipts
-
E-filing: You receive an electronic acknowledgment (acceptance or rejection) and a PDF copy of your filed return from the software or tax pro—keep these along with W-2s/1099s for at least three years (IRS guidance). Electronic records are easy to store and back up.
-
Paper filing: Keep a photocopy and use certified mail or tracking if you want proof of timely filing. Physical copies are subject to damage or loss.
Common mistakes and misconceptions
- Myth: E-filing is inherently less secure. Reality: E-file uses encryption and vendor security controls; mailed documents can be intercepted.
- Mistake: Using unvetted free software or sites—only use IRS-authorized e-file providers or reputable vendors.
- Mistake: Waiting until the deadline to e-file—late submission risks server congestion and missed corrections if rejected.
Troubleshooting: rejections, errors, and identity flags
If your e-file is rejected, common fixes include:
- Confirm SSN/name matches Social Security Administration records.
- Enter prior-year AGI or electronic PIN correctly.
- Correct duplicate filing issues (someone else filed for you) or resolved identity theft concerns.
For rejected or questioned returns, our practical guide shows common causes and next steps: What to Do When the IRS Rejects Your E-File (finhelp.io/glossary/what-to-do-when-the-irs-rejects-your-e-file/). If the IRS places a refund hold for identity verification or the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC), respond promptly to any IRS letters and follow the verification steps. See also our guidance on speeding refunds: Speeding Up Your Refund: Common Holdups and How to Avoid Them (finhelp.io/glossary/speeding-up-your-refund-common-holdups-and-how-to-avoid-them/).
How to decide: a short decision checklist
- Do you need a fast refund? E-file + direct deposit.
- Is your return simple (W-2s, standard deduction)? E-file is efficient and cheap (or free).
- Do you lack reliable internet or prefer paper records? Consider paper or visit a VITA site that can e-file for you.
- Are you worried about identity theft? E-file can still be safe, but take steps: use reputable vendors, enable two-factor authentication, and monitor IRS notices.
- Are you filing an amended return or an unusual form? Check the IRS and our guidance about e-filing availability for specific forms (finhelp.io/glossary/can-you-e-file-form-1040x/).
Practical tips to minimize problems
- File early. Early e-filing reduces the chance someone else files using your information.
- Choose direct deposit to speed refunds and reduce lost-check risk.
- Keep organized digital and paper copies of W-2s, 1099s, and receipts for at least three years.
- Use IRS Free File or an IRS-authorized e-file provider when possible (IRS e-file options).
- If mailing, use certified mail or tracked postage and keep the receipt.
Final thoughts from practice
In my experience working with clients for over 15 years, e-filing solves most routine problems: faster refunds, fewer math errors, and better confirmation. Paper filings still make sense for a small minority—either by necessity or by choice—but expect longer waits and plan accordingly. If you’re unsure which route fits your situation, a brief conversation with a tax preparer can clarify whether you can (and should) e-file this year.
Professional disclaimer: This article is educational and not individualized tax advice. For specific tax decisions, consult a licensed tax professional or the IRS. Authoritative sources used: IRS filing guidance (https://www.irs.gov/filing/e-file-options) and related IRS pages; additional FinHelp articles linked above provide deeper, situation-specific guidance.
