Quick overview

Filing in the U.S. Tax Court gives taxpayers a forum to contest federal income-tax deficiencies proposed by the IRS without first paying the disputed amount. The most common trigger is a Notice of Deficiency (often called a “90-day letter”); if you receive one, you typically have 90 days from the date the notice is mailed (150 days if you live outside the United States) to file a petition in Tax Court (U.S. Tax Court; IRS). Missing that deadline usually ends your Tax Court option and allows the IRS to assess and start collection.

In my practice advising clients on tax controversies, I’ve seen timely petitions preserve cash flow, force the IRS to clarify its position, and create opportunities to settle on better terms. Below I explain the key stages, deadlines, strategic choices, and practical tips to help you decide whether to file.

How does a case reach Tax Court?

  1. IRS audit or review leads to proposed adjustments.
  2. The IRS issues a Notice of Deficiency describing proposed changes and the amount it intends to assess.
  3. The taxpayer files a petition in the U.S. Tax Court within the statutory time (normally 90 days) to contest the proposed deficiency without paying it first (U.S. Tax Court; IRS Appeals).

If you do not receive a Notice of Deficiency but disagree with an assessment that has already been made, your remedy is generally a refund suit in federal district court or the U.S. Court of Federal Claims after paying the tax. This is the key distinction: Tax Court is typically the prepayment venue.

For a breakdown of common triggers and when a notice of deficiency is issued, see our article: “What Triggers a Notice of Deficiency and When to Consider Tax Court” (FinHelp.io).

Key deadlines and jurisdiction

  • Notice of Deficiency: The IRS has a statutory window to mail this after an audit. Once mailed, the taxpayer normally has 90 days (or 150 days if outside the U.S.) to file a petition in Tax Court. This timeframe is strict; courts rarely excuse late filing.

  • Collection Due Process (CDP) cases and other limited petitions have different, shorter deadlines — often 30 days — so read notices carefully and act quickly (IRS). If you received a CDP notice, you may also seek Tax Court review after following the IRS Appeals process.

  • Appeals: If you lose in Tax Court, you can appeal to the appropriate U.S. Court of Appeals. If you want to sue for a refund after paying a tax, your appeal path is different (district court or Court of Federal Claims).

For guidance on venue selection and the pros/cons of other forums, see: “Tax Court vs. U.S. District Court: Choosing the Right Venue” (FinHelp.io).

Petition requirements and filing mechanics

A Tax Court petition is a formal court pleading. Basic elements typically include:

  • The petitioner’s name, address, and tax year(s) at issue.
  • A clear statement of the amount and the specific IRS adjustments being challenged.
  • Jurisdictional allegations (that you received a Notice of Deficiency, with the date).
  • A prayer for relief (what you want the court to rule).

Petitions must be filed with the Tax Court and served on the U.S. government. The court provides forms and an electronic filing system (CM/ECF) for practitioners; pro se (unrepresented) filers can consult Tax Court filing guidance (U.S. Tax Court).

If you need step-by-step instructions on filing, see: “How to Petition the U.S. Tax Court” (FinHelp.io).

Small Tax Case (S case) vs. Regular Tax Court case

  • Small Tax Case (Tax Court’s Small Tax Case Division) is available when the amount in dispute does not exceed the statutory limit (check the Tax Court website for the current threshold). Small cases have simpler procedures and are faster, but Tax Court decisions in small cases are not precedential.

  • Regular Tax Court cases follow full litigation procedures, including discovery, motions, pre-trial memoranda, and often longer timelines. A full decision becomes precedent for the Tax Court.

Choosing the small-claims route can make sense for straightforward, lower-dollar disputes. For complex legal issues or larger amounts, the regular docket is usually preferable.

Burden of proof and evidence

Generally, the taxpayer bears the burden of proof to show that the IRS’s proposed adjustment is incorrect. However, under certain circumstances the burden of proof may shift to the IRS if the taxpayer introduces credible evidence and satisfies the requirements of Internal Revenue Code §7491 (e.g., keeping adequate records and cooperating). Discuss this threshold with counsel early — it can materially affect strategy.

Document everything. Good substantiation (receipts, bank records, contemporaneous business logs, expert reports) is often decisive. In my experience, cases resolved in the taxpayer’s favor almost always include clear, well-organized documentary evidence and a concise timeline that ties the facts to the relevant tax rules.

Pre-trial procedure, discovery, and settlement

After a petition is filed, the parties enter pre-trial stages: exchanging information, taking depositions in some cases, filing motions, and participating in settlement discussions or pre-trial conferences. Many Tax Court cases settle before trial. Settlement can be efficient, but negotiate with a clear understanding of the tax, penalties, and interest implications.

Discovery in Tax Court is narrower than in some civil courts, but you can obtain documents, admissions, and witness testimony. Be mindful of deadlines for disclosure and motions.

Typical timeline and costs

  • Timeline: From petition to trial can range from several months to a few years depending on complexity and court backlog. Small Tax Case timelines are shorter.

  • Costs: Filing fees are modest, but legal and expert costs can be significant for complex cases. Balance the projected tax exposure, potential penalties, and your cash position when deciding whether to litigate. In many cases, a targeted settlement or administrative appeal provides the best net outcome.

Strategic considerations — when to file and when to settle

  1. Preserve rights vs. cash flow: Filing in Tax Court preserves your right to challenge the deficiency without paying first — a major tactical advantage, especially for small businesses with limited liquidity.
  2. Strength of documentation: If records are weak, consider alternatives (settlement, Appeals) unless you can reconstruct credible evidence.
  3. Complexity of legal issue: Novel legal questions may warrant full Tax Court litigation to obtain a precedential ruling.
  4. Risk tolerance and cost-benefit: Litigation brings uncertainty and expense; realistic assessment of likely recovery vs. cost is essential.

If you’re unsure where to start, our comparison pieces can help: “Appeals vs Small Claims Tax Court: Which Is Right for You” and “Tax Court vs. U.S. District Court: Choosing the Right Venue” (FinHelp.io).

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Missing the 90/150-day filing deadline.
  • Treating Tax Court like an informal negotiation forum — it’s a court with strict procedural rules.
  • Failing to organize and label your evidence; poorly presented exhibits reduce persuasive impact.
  • Assuming Tax Court decisions are always private; regular decisions are public and can establish precedent.

Practical filing checklist

  • Read the Notice of Deficiency carefully and note mailing date.
  • Confirm whether you’re inside or outside the U.S. (90 vs 150 days).
  • Gather records for the tax years in dispute: returns, receipts, bank statements, contracts, invoices.
  • Decide whether to engage a tax lawyer, CPA, or enrolled agent experienced in Tax Court practice.
  • Prepare and file the petition; serve the U.S. government and retain proof of service.
  • Prepare an initial reply and consider early settlement discussions with IRS Appeals.

After a Tax Court decision

If you win, the IRS will generally abate the deficiency and related penalties for the tax years involved. If you lose, you can appeal to the appropriate U.S. Court of Appeals. Tax Court decisions on legal issues can affect many taxpayers, so consult counsel about follow-up steps, including collection and payment planning.

Where to learn more (authoritative sources)

  • U.S. Tax Court: USTaxCourt.gov — official rules, forms, and filing guidance (U.S. Tax Court).
  • Internal Revenue Service: Appeals and notices guidance (IRS Appeals) and general taxpayer guidance (IRS.gov).

Final practical tips from my experience

  • Act immediately when you receive a notice. The clock runs fast.
  • Organize records by tax year and issue. A one-page chronology can make your case easier to evaluate.
  • Use the Tax Court’s small case option for straightforward, lower-dollar disputes if eligible.
  • Consider the benefits of early negotiation with IRS Appeals; sometimes a low-cost settlement avoids lengthy litigation.

Professional disclaimer: This article is educational only and not individualized legal or tax advice. Tax controversies often involve unique facts—consult a tax attorney or CPA experienced in Tax Court practice to evaluate your situation.

References

Internal resources