Quick summary

This guide explains the federal filing rules that most affect sellers using Amazon, eBay, Etsy, payment apps, and other online marketplaces. It covers how information returns work, what sellers must report on their tax return, practical recordkeeping steps, and common problems that trigger IRS notices.

How marketplace reporting works (at a glance)

  • Platforms that process payments for sellers are often treated as third‑party settlement organizations and may issue Form 1099‑K to report gross payments they processed for you to both you and the IRS (IRS – About Form 1099‑K).
  • Separately, sellers themselves must report all taxable income on Form 1040. Business sellers generally use Schedule C (or Form 1120/1120‑S for incorporated businesses) and may owe self‑employment tax (Schedule SE) on net earnings (IRS – Schedule C (Form 1040); IRS – Self‑Employment Tax).
  • Information returns (1099‑K and 1099‑NEC) are reporting tools — they do not replace the taxpayer’s responsibility to report all income.

Reporting thresholds and practical context

  • Historically, third‑party settlement organizations reported payments when gross payments exceeded $20,000 AND there were more than 200 transactions. The American Rescue Plan Act reduced the statutory threshold to $600, but platform implementation varied for a transition period. Because companies and IRS guidance changed over 2022–2024, the practical result is that some sellers began receiving more 1099‑Ks at lower thresholds while others still saw older thresholds applied. Regardless of whether you receive a 1099‑K, you must report all income.

  • Separate from 1099‑K rules, a payer who directly hires a contractor should issue Form 1099‑NEC for nonemployee compensation of $600 or more in a tax year (IRS – Form 1099‑NEC instructions). Marketplaces that mark sales as “transactions processed” typically use 1099‑K rather than 1099‑NEC.

Note: Because platform practices evolved, check each marketplace’s reporting notices for the tax year in question and keep your own records. Platforms will often post a help article and the form itself when they issue 1099‑Ks.

What sellers must file on their tax return

  • Report total gross receipts from sales and services on your federal tax return. If you run a business, report gross receipts and allowable business expenses on Schedule C (Form 1040). The net profit from Schedule C flows to Form 1040 and may be subject to income tax and self‑employment tax.

  • If you sell personal items at a loss (e.g., used household goods sold for less than purchase price), those receipts are typically not taxable as they are personal‑use property sales. If you sell items for profit or operate with a profit intent, treat the activity as a business.

  • If you receive a 1099‑K, reconcile it to your own records. The 1099‑K reports gross payments processed, which can include shipping collected, sales tax, or refunds. You should report income net of returns only when calculating net profit; gross receipts reported on Schedule C should match your business records, not necessarily the 1099‑K line‑by‑line.

Practical steps to stay compliant

  1. Track every sale and related cost. Use a spreadsheet or accounting software (QuickBooks, Wave, etc.) to capture: date, platform, gross sales, fees, refunds, shipping charged, cost of goods sold (COGS), and direct expenses.
  2. Reconcile monthly platform statements to bank deposits and to any 1099‑K you receive.
  3. Separate business and personal accounts to reduce bookkeeping errors and simplify tracking deductible expenses.
  4. Save receipts and proof for deductions (inventory costs, shipping, platform fees, home office allocation if eligible).
  5. If you expect to owe tax because of net profit, pay estimated quarterly tax to avoid penalties (use Form 1040‑ES guidance).

Examples to clarify reporting vs. withholding

  • Example: A seller receives a 1099‑K showing $3,000 in gross payments. The platform withheld sales tax and collected $150 in shipping, and the seller paid $600 in platform fees and $900 cost of goods sold. On Schedule C the seller reports $3,000 gross receipts, then deducts $600 platform fees and $900 COGS to arrive at $1,500 net profit (subject to income and self‑employment tax). The 1099‑K supports gross receipts but isn’t the final taxable amount.

  • Example: A casual seller sells household items in a one‑time garage‑sale style online and realizes a loss: proceeds are not taxable. But if the activity is regular and profit‑seeking (buy items wholesale and resell), treat it as business income.

Common mistakes and how to avoid them

  • Thinking you only report income when you get a 1099‑K: False — all income must be reported. The 1099‑K is an information return, not the tax return.
  • Ignoring differences between gross reported on a 1099‑K and your taxable gross receipts: reconcile fees, refunds, and sales tax.
  • Mixing personal and business transactions: use separate accounts and cards.
  • Failing to pay estimated taxes: if you expect tax due of $1,000 or more when filing, you likely need to make quarterly payments.

When platforms issue a 1099‑K and you disagree

If the 1099‑K shows an amount you believe is wrong:

  1. Contact the platform for an explanation and ask for corrected reporting if they made an error.
  2. Keep documentation showing what you actually received and why some items on the 1099‑K shouldn’t be included in gross income (e.g., sales tax collected and remitted separately to a state).
  3. Report the correct amounts on your return and keep supporting records in case of an IRS information‑return mismatch notice. FinHelp has a practical guide on reconciling mismatched 1099s that walks through next steps and sample correspondence (Reconciling Mismatched 1099s: When Payers and Payees Disagree).

State sales tax and marketplace facilitator rules

Marketplace facilitator laws (state rules) may require the platform to collect and remit sales tax on behalf of sellers. That is separate from federal income reporting — you still report income for federal tax purposes even if the marketplace collects sales tax. Check your state’s department of revenue and the marketplace’s seller policies.

Helpful resources and internal guidance

Frequently asked questions

Q: If I earned less than a platform’s 1099‑K threshold, do I still file?
A: Yes. You must report all taxable income regardless of whether the platform sends a 1099‑K.

Q: Are refunds and sales tax included in the 1099‑K?
A: Platforms report gross payments. Sales tax collected or refunds processed can be included in the gross figure. Reconcile the platform’s detail report to determine your correct gross receipts and deductions.

Q: When should I treat an activity as a business instead of a hobby?
A: The IRS looks at factors like profit motive, businesslike practices, time and effort, and reliance on income. If you operate regularly, keep records, and aim for profit, treat the activity as a business and report on Schedule C.

Action checklist (at tax time)

  • Collect all 1099s (K, NEC) and platform statements.
  • Reconcile platform gross receipts to your own records.
  • Prepare Schedule C (or corporate return if incorporated) and Schedule SE if applicable.
  • Keep receipts for COGS, shipping, fees, and other business expenses.
  • Pay estimated taxes during the year if you expect to owe.

Professional note from the author

In my 15+ years advising online sellers, the single biggest compliance win is consistent recordkeeping. Sellers who treat their online activity like a business from day one avoid stress, reduce audit risk, and maximize legitimate deductions.

Disclaimer

This article is educational and does not replace professional tax advice. Tax rules and platform reporting practices can change; consult a qualified tax professional for guidance specific to your facts and the tax year in question.

Related FinHelp articles