Quick overview

Refinancing can be a powerful financial tool when used intentionally. A rate-and-term refinance is designed to change the interest rate, the length of the mortgage, or both—without taking new cash out of your home. A cash-out refinance replaces your existing mortgage with a larger loan and pays you the difference in cash that you can use for renovations, debt consolidation, college, or other expenses.

This article explains how each option works, typical costs and eligibility rules, tax and long-term implications, real-world examples, a decision checklist, and professional tips to help homeowners decide which path is right for them.

Sources: Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) guidance on refinancing and cash-out refinances; IRS Publication 936 on mortgage interest deduction. See CFPB: https://www.consumerfinance.gov and IRS: https://www.irs.gov/publications/p936.

How each refinance works and when homeowners use it

Rate-and-term refinance

  • Purpose: Lower monthly payments, shorten loan term to save interest, or change from an adjustable-rate mortgage (ARM) to a fixed-rate mortgage (or vice versa).
  • Mechanics: Lender pays off the current mortgage and issues a new loan sized to the remaining balance. Closing costs apply, and the borrower’s equity does not change materially (other than normal amortization and any closing-cost-related adjustments).
  • Typical use-cases: Falling interest rates, desire to accelerate payoff (e.g., move from 30-year to 15-year), or switching to a more stable rate type.

Cash-out refinance

  • Purpose: Convert a portion of home equity into cash at closing while obtaining a new mortgage.
  • Mechanics: Lender pays off the existing mortgage and issues a new loan larger than the payoff amount. You receive the difference in cash; your new loan balance increases and may change your monthly payment and total interest paid over time.
  • Typical uses: Home improvements that increase value, consolidating higher-interest debt, funding education costs, or providing liquidity for a one-time need.

Author’s note: In my 15+ years advising homeowners, cash-out refinances are most effective when the homeowner has a clear plan to use the funds for value-creating purposes (e.g., renovations that raise market value or replacing higher-cost debt). Using cash for short-term consumption without a repayment plan often creates longer-term strain.

Costs, fees, and break-even considerations

Both refinance types usually carry similar closing costs: appraisal, title search, title insurance, lender fees, underwriting, and escrow charges. Typical ranges are 1%–5% of the new loan amount depending on loan type and location.

  • Rate-and-term: Because the loan amount typically equals the payoff, closing costs are paid out of pocket or rolled into the loan, and many borrowers calculate a break-even period (months until monthly savings exceed upfront costs) to determine if refinancing is worthwhile. See our deeper guidance on refinancing timing: Mortgage Refinancing: When to Refinance and Cost Considerations.
  • Cash-out: Closing costs may be higher because the lender takes a larger loan on which certain fees scale and an appraisal is almost always required. Rolling costs into the larger loan increases the financed amount and extends the period before any savings are realized.

Break-even example: If refinancing costs $4,000 and the new loan reduces your monthly payment by $200, break-even is 20 months ($4,000 / $200). But that ignores the impact of extending term or increasing total interest for cash-out loans—so always run a total-cost comparison, not just monthly payment math.

Eligibility and common program limits

Eligibility depends on credit score, debt-to-income (DTI), property type, occupancy (primary vs. investment), and loan-to-value (LTV) or combined LTV (CLTV) limits set by each program (conventional, FHA, VA, USDA).

  • Conventional (Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac): Cash-out refinances commonly cap CLTV around 80% for primary residences (program rules vary by property type and loan size). Rate-and-term refinances can allow higher LTVs because no cash is taken out. Check program matrices for current limits.
  • FHA and VA: These programs have different rules and may allow higher LTVs under specific circumstances but also impose their own lending requirements and mortgage insurance implications.

For a focused discussion of how cash-out refis affect qualification, see: How Cash-Out Refinance Affects Debt-to-Income Calculations.

Authoritative source: The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau provides plain-language overviews of refinance types and program differences (CFPB: https://www.consumerfinance.gov).

Tax and long-term financial impacts

  • Mortgage interest deductibility: Interest on mortgage debt remains potentially deductible only when the loan proceeds are used to buy, build, or substantially improve the taxpayer’s home (see IRS Publication 936). If a cash-out refinance funds home improvements, interest on that portion may be deductible; if it pays for private expenses, the deduction rules differ. Always consult a tax professional. (IRS: https://www.irs.gov/publications/p936)

  • Long-term cost: A rate-and-term refinance that shortens the term typically reduces total interest paid. A cash-out refinance increases the principal and almost always increases total interest paid over the life of the loan unless the cash is used to eliminate higher-cost debt or invest in higher-return assets.

  • Equity and risk: Cashing out reduces home equity and can leave you closer to negative equity if home values fall. That matters for selling or future financing options.

Pros and cons — at a glance

Rate-and-term refinance

Pros:

  • Lowers monthly payments or total interest if you secure a lower rate or shorten term.
  • Preserves home equity.
  • Often simpler underwriting than cash-out.

Cons:

  • Closing costs can negate short-term monthly savings if you plan to move soon.
  • Some borrowers roll costs into the new loan and extend repayment.

Cash-out refinance

Pros:

  • Provides immediate lump-sum cash at usually lower rates than unsecured borrowing.
  • Can consolidate higher-interest debt and reduce total interest if used properly.

Cons:

  • Increases mortgage balance and monthly payment (unless lower rate offset equals or reduces payment).
  • May increase total interest paid and reduce equity.
  • Qualification limits (LTV/CLTV) and mortgage insurance requirements may apply.

For help deciding between options, see our comparison piece: Refinance vs. Cash-Out Refinance: Pros and Cons.

Decision checklist for homeowners

  1. Clarify the goal: lower payment, pay off faster, or get cash?
  2. Run total-cost calculations: include closing costs, new rate, new term, and the impact on total interest paid.
  3. Check program limits: LTV/CLTV, mortgage insurance, DTI rules.
  4. Compare alternatives: HELOCs, home equity loans, personal loans, or credit-card paydown.
  5. Consider timing: plan to stay in the home longer than the break-even period to recoup costs.
  6. Tax impact: determine if interest remains deductible for the intended use of funds (consult a tax advisor).

Real-world examples (cleaned and practical)

  • Rate-and-term example: A homeowner with a 30-year mortgage at 4.75% refinance to a 30-year at 3.75%. If closing costs are $3,600 and monthly savings are $180, the break-even is 20 months. If the homeowner plans to stay 5+ years, the refinance likely makes sense.

  • Cash-out example: A homeowner with $200,000 outstanding and $300,000 home value (67% LTV) does a cash-out to borrow $260,000 and receives $60,000 cash. If the new rate is slightly lower but the term resets to 30 years, total interest may increase markedly—even if monthly payment stays similar. If the $60,000 is used to pay off 18% credit-card debt, overall household interest costs could fall substantially. Work through both scenarios.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Treating monthly payment reduction as the only metric. Total cost and equity impact matter.
  • Using cash-out proceeds for nondiscriminating consumption without contingency for repayment.
  • Forgetting mortgage interest tax limits and the IRS rules about use of proceeds.

Final guidance and next steps

If your objective is to lower payment or shorten the loan without increasing debt, a rate-and-term refinance is often the better fit. If you need a controlled amount of cash and you have sufficient equity, a cash-out refinance can be efficient—provided you understand the long-term tradeoffs and confirm program eligibility.

Start by getting detailed Loan Estimates from two or three lenders and run a side-by-side total-cost comparison. Review program rules carefully and consult a CPA about the tax treatment of refinance proceeds.

Professional disclaimer: This article is educational and not individualized financial, tax, or legal advice. Consult a mortgage professional and a tax advisor for guidance specific to your situation.

Authoritative resources

Internal resources