Why investors consider alternative assets
Alternative assets are uses of capital that fall outside the familiar trio of stocks, bonds and cash. Investors add them to portfolios to reduce overall volatility, seek sources of return that aren’t tightly correlated with public markets, or gain exposure to specific real‑world assets (like rental property or precious metals). The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission and FINRA both advise that alternatives can offer benefits but require more investor homework than mutual funds or exchange‑traded funds (SEC; FINRA).
In my practice working with individual and high‑net‑worth clients, I’ve seen alternatives smooth returns during equity drawdowns and add meaningful income streams (for example, rental cash flow or private debt coupons). But those outcomes depend on careful selection, realistic allocation, and a long time horizon.
How alternative investments work (basic mechanics)
Alternatives differ from traditional public investments in three structural ways:
- Liquidity: Many alternatives are illiquid or have lockups (private equity, many hedge funds, real estate syndications). Liquidity windows can be years, not days.
- Valuation: Private assets often lack daily market prices. Valuations rely on periodic appraisals, fund reports, or broker quotes.
- Access & regulation: Some alternatives (private equity, hedge funds, certain funds of funds) are limited to accredited investors and involve additional regulatory disclosures (SEC, Regulation D).
Because of these differences, alternatives play a tactical or strategic role rather than functioning as direct substitutes for core stock or bond holdings.
Common categories and what to expect
-
Real estate: Direct property ownership, REITs, and syndications. Real estate can provide rental income and potential appreciation, plus tax strategies like depreciation and 1031‑style exchanges for property investors. For how to structure or protect real estate holdings, see practical guides such as our article on Real Estate Investing and managing liability with LLCs in Using LLCs for Real Estate Liability Management.
-
Commodities: Physical goods (gold, oil, agricultural products) and commodity futures. These can hedge inflation or currency risk but carry storage, roll yield, and price volatility considerations.
-
Private equity & venture capital: Equity stakes in private companies. Potentially higher return but longer lockups, higher failure rates, and significant due diligence.
-
Hedge funds and alternative mutual funds: Pooled investment vehicles that pursue non‑traditional strategies (long/short, arbitrage, derivatives). Often complex fee structures (2/20 historically) and strategy risk.
-
Private debt & direct lending: Loans to businesses or real estate projects. Lower correlation with public credit markets but credit and servicing risk.
-
Collectibles and tangible assets: Art, classic cars, coins, wine. Value is driven by scarcity, provenance and market demand; storage and authenticity are practical concerns.
Who should consider alternatives (eligibility and suitability)
Alternatives can suit a range of investors, but suitability depends on capital, time horizon, and goals:
- Accredited/high‑net‑worth investors: Some private funds require accredited investor status under SEC rules (Rule 501, Regulation D). These investors often gain access to private equity, certain hedge funds, and specialty offerings.
- Individual investors with longer horizons and higher risk tolerance: Real estate syndications or business loans can be appropriate if you can tolerate illiquidity.
- Investors seeking non‑correlated income or inflation protection: Commodities, real assets and some private credit strategies may fit.
Always match the investment’s liquidity profile to your cash needs. If you cannot tolerate holding an investment for several years, highly illiquid alternatives are usually inappropriate.
Allocation guidance: How much is reasonable?
There is no one‑size‑fits‑all allocation. Many financial planners recommend a modest initial allocation—commonly 5–20% of investable assets—scaled by net worth, objectives and the investor’s ability to absorb losses. Lower allocations (5–10%) provide exposure with limited balance‑sheet impact; higher allocations (15–20%+) are typically reserved for experienced or high‑net‑worth investors who can access private markets and accept illiquidity.
Key constraints to consider when sizing allocations:
- Emergency liquidity needs: Keep 3–12 months of cash separate from alternative allocations.
- Diversification within alternatives: A single real estate deal is concentrated; spreading capital among different property types, geographies or strategies reduces idiosyncratic risk.
- Fees and drag: High management and performance fees reduce net returns—model net returns, not headline IRRs.
Due diligence checklist before investing
- Strategy clarity: Can the manager explain how they generate returns? What are the key risks?
- Track record and people: Review audited performance history and the team’s experience.
- Fees and waterfall: Understand management fees, performance share, and how returns are split.
- Liquidity terms: Lockup period, redemption windows and gates.
- Valuation methodology: How often and by whom are assets valued?
- Legal documents and disclosures: Read the private placement memorandum, subscription agreements, and investor rights.
- Tax implications: Get clarity on K‑1s, unrelated business taxable income (UBTI), or retirement account limits.
Tax and retirement account considerations
Tax treatment varies by asset type. Real estate may offer depreciation and 1031‑style strategies for property exchanges (consult a tax advisor), while private funds often issue K‑1s that complicate tax filings. Importantly, certain assets are restricted in retirement accounts: the IRS disallows collectibles in IRAs and imposes strict prohibited transaction rules—violations can create taxes and penalties (IRS guidance on prohibited investments). If you plan to hold alternatives in an IRA or 401(k), verify that your custodian allows them and understand reporting requirements.
Common risks and misconceptions
- ‘‘Alternatives always outperform’’ is false. Performance varies widely by manager, vintage year and luck.
- Illiquidity is often underestimated. Selling private stakes can take months or years and may require accepting steep discounts.
- Fees can neutralize alpha. A gross‑of‑fee return may look attractive until management and incentive fees are applied.
Practical examples (short case studies)
-
Income diversification: During a market slump, a client’s diversified portfolio included a private mortgage fund that continued to pay interest; the fund’s lower correlation with equities reduced the portfolio’s drawdown.
-
Concentration risk: Another client invested a large share of savings into a single collectible (classic car). When tastes shifted, the asset underperformed for several years and created a liquidity crunch.
These examples highlight why allocation discipline and diversification within alternatives matter.
Steps to add alternatives to a personal plan
- Define the role: Are you using alternatives for income, inflation hedge, or uncorrelated returns?
- Size conservatively: Start small and increase exposure only after positive experience and strong due diligence.
- Use reputable intermediaries or custodian solutions when possible—public REITs or listed commodity ETFs can be liquid, lower‑cost proxies for direct exposure.
- Coordinate taxes and estate planning: Alternatives often have different tax and transfer consequences—consult a CPA and estate attorney.
Where to learn more (authoritative resources)
- U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) investor education on alternative investments. (SEC)
- FINRA guidance on alternative investments and suitability. (FINRA)
- IRS guidance on retirement account prohibited investments and tax treatment for collectibles and private activity. (IRS)
Internal resources
- For hands‑on real estate topics, see our beginner guide on Real Estate Investing.
- To understand entity and liability issues when holding property, read Using LLCs for Real Estate Liability Management.
Bottom line
Alternative assets can be a useful complement to traditional portfolios when used deliberately: set a clear role, size allocations conservatively, and perform thorough due diligence. They are not a silver bullet—expect higher complexity, potential illiquidity, and distinct tax consequences. Speak to a fiduciary financial planner and tax professional before allocating material capital to alternatives.
Disclaimer: This article is educational and not individualized investment advice. It does not recommend specific securities or funds. Consult your financial advisor or tax professional about how alternative investments fit your circumstances.
